Politics

The Art Of War -- Iraqi Style

MayorBob.

Posted to Politics on Sun Nov 12, 2006 at 09:11:58 AM EST (promoted by port1080). RSS.

"War is hell" is the line attributed to General William T. Sherman, uttered as his Union forces advanced on the sea to explain the devastation wrought to the Georgia countryside along the way.  Had anyone asked Robert E. Lee, leading the Confederate forces, if he agreed with Sherman, they might have gotten an answer in the affirmative -- "It is well that war is so terrible, or we should grow too fond of it."  More recently, the president's mom Barbara Bush described war as "not nice."  Most of us, living in states believing in civilian control of the military would endorse former French Prime Minister Georges Clemenceau's observation that "war is much too serious a matter to be entrusted to the military."  Following the latest explanation of the state of things in Iraq by a general in Iraq, we might want to amend Clemenceau's statement to add: "war is too serious a matter to be explained by the military."

Just when you thought you had heard the stupidest, most insensitive comparison of what's going on over in Iraq to anything else, along comes US Army Major General William Caldwell, spokesperson of the Central Command to compare the carnage and bloodshed taking place in Iraq as "a work of art."  The last time Caldwell was featured in the media was when the death of Abu Musab al-Zarqawi was being reported.  That was replete with video shots of the airstrikes which killed al-Zarqawi along with a nice head shot of the dead terrorist.  But this time, Caldwell didn't have any back up videos or pictures to entertain the press so he decided to wax eloquent:

"Every great work of art goes through messy phases while it is in transition. A lump of clay can become a sculpture. Blobs of paint become paintings which inspire."
Coming as it did a full four months since Caldwell effusively remarked that "the days of Zarqawi are over" observing that "now Iraqis from their neighborhoods to the halls of their government can rejoice and take great pride in what has been accomplished by both them and the coalition forces in eliminating that threat."  That's four full months of bloodshed and misery, suffered by the Iraqi public and US forces in country - four months during which 350 coalition soldiers have given up their lives and between 5,700 and 6,100 Iraqi civilians have been killed.  One wonders what sort of work of art, Major General Caldwell has in mind.

That's exactly the sort of question which occurred to two Democratic US Senators.  Carl Levin of Michigan said he might be able to see the comparison if things "were moving in the right direction" but, by "Central Command's own portrayal" they're clearly not, in Levin's estimation.  Jack Reed of Rhode Island (a West Point graduate) observed "West Point was never recognized for its fine-arts program" and agreed with Levin that the numbers and the news indicate we're "losing the initiative."  Time for you to play art critic and, taking what you know and feel about the war in Iraq, come up with your candidate for the artistic expression which you feel comes closest to describing our Iraq adventure.

Tags: written by Mayorbob, edited by Port1080, art, war, Iraq, dumb (all tags)

This story: 18 comments (5 from subqueue)
Post a Comment
1

A close analogy

anykey.

Sun Nov 12, 2006 at 10:18:11 AM EST

5.00 (funny, funny)

A Jehovah's Witness in a clown suit trying to make an cheese omlette with a chainsaw at bottom of a shark tank.

"Peculiar travel suggestions are dancing lessons from God."

2

Art

1fastdog.

Sun Nov 12, 2006 at 10:28:13 AM EST

5.00 (astute)

Time for you to play art critic and, taking what you know and feel about the war in Iraq, come up with your candidate for the artistic expression which you feel comes closest to describing our Iraq adventure.

Okay, here goes:
A mad U.S. president (who's really just a clown at heart), at the behest of interested parties and think tanks, decide to wage war and also decide to hand off control of their little foray in nation-building to an architect with a flair for slapstick buffoonery.

I think that about does it.

Somewhere in my soul, there's always Rock -n- Roll... Joe Strummer

5

^ 2

A missing element

Lou.

Sun Nov 12, 2006 at 01:20:49 PM EST

5.00 (informative)

Slapstick is all well and good,  but you also need an example of subtle humor to make it complete.

It's the end of the world as we know it, and I feel fine

3

I'll let the art critics weigh in on the art.

MayorBob.

Sun Nov 12, 2006 at 11:24:56 AM EST

5.00 (astute)

I want to talk about the lunacy in referring to the war in Iraq as a "work of art."  Coming as I do, from the perspective of the Vietnam War, I remember an Army officer saying, "we had to destroy the village to save it" referring to the devastation visited upon a Vietnamese village because they it was thoroughly infiltrated by the VC.  I'd have to put these two quotes from Iraq right up there in terms of stupidity as General Caldwell's gem:

  1.  "Freedom's untidy, and free people are free to make mistakes and commit crimes and do bad things" -- Donald Rumsfeld

  2.  "My belief is we will, in fact, be greeted as liberators" -- Dick Cheney

and my nomination for the single, stupidest quote to emerge from the war in Iraq:

3. "My answer is bring 'em on" -- George W. Bush.  Over three years and close to 3,000 American lives later, I guess you might say the terrorists heard him and brought it on.  Heckuva job, Georgie!

Illegitimi non carborundum.

6

^ 3

Three more good ones

anykey.

Sun Nov 12, 2006 at 05:15:22 PM EST

5.00 (astute)

The "end of major combat operations" quote would have to be right up there.

So would the original White House estimate of "50 to 60 billion" dollars for the war.

And Bush's: "You can't distinguish between Al-Qaeda and Saddam when you talk about the war on terror"

"Peculiar travel suggestions are dancing lessons from God."

9

^ 6

Re: Three more good ones

Shy Elf.

Mon Nov 13, 2006 at 06:33:09 AM EST

none

My stupidest quotes from this war are "Crusade" and "Jihadi".

The "end of major combat operations" phrase never struck me as wrong.  Except for Fallujah, it was the end of major combat operations.  The only problem was the 20,000 minor combat operations.  Even if the Bush camp denies setting it up, I still prefer "Mission Accomplished".  And the Shiia did greet us as liberators.

For anti-war art, keep it simple.  Take some boots and throw 150,000 flower petals on them.  Experiment with different objects and techniques.  It speaks for itself.

The Caldwell quote really needs a strip of it being read on a radio as a three-year-old attempts to make some statues with play-doh which turn out to be hideous and cause her to give up and start crying.

The best actually good quote would be the Pottery Barn Rule, which skilled jokester John Kerry explains as "If you break it, you fix it. Now, if you break it, you made a mistake. It's the wrong thing to do. But you own it."  We've sure bought the pumpkin on that one.

11

^ 3

Re: I'll let the art critics weigh in on the art.

wetkarma.

Tue Nov 14, 2006 at 12:51:39 PM EST

none


3. "My answer is bring 'em on" -- George W. Bush.  Over three years and close to 3,000 American lives later, I guess you might say the terrorists heard him and brought it on.  Heckuva job, Georgie!

Meh. My perspective on that (to the terrorists) is: Is that the best you can do?

I thought that bring 'em on quote was politically inept at the time it was made but the general sentiment I strongly support. It is an attitude of fearlessness and righteous (misplaced) anger stemming from the 9/11.

For me there can be no detente, no hudna with Al Qaeda and its fellow travellers. Its unfortunate that the administration has conflated this enemy with that of those who fighting us in Iraq for various and sundry reasons. But if the administration posture is going to be kill em all and let gawd sort em out, I'm willing to back it far more so than lobbying cruise missiles at empty camps.

Memory is a strange bell, jubilee and knell.

12

^ 11

Re: I'll let the art critics weigh in on the art.

Lou.

Tue Nov 14, 2006 at 01:35:14 PM EST

none

ar more so than lobbying cruise missiles at empty camps.

Shit, it seems like everyone has their grubby corporate fingers in DC politics.  First the big conglomerates, now frickin' missles.  What's next?  Pedophile Priests for Consent Reform?

I'm curious though...what would a lobbyist cruise missle wear to work?

It's the end of the world as we know it, and I feel fine

13

^ 12

Re: I'll let the art critics weigh in on the art.

Coelacanth.

Wed Nov 15, 2006 at 06:37:31 AM EST

none

I'm curious though...what would a lobbyist cruise missile wear to work?

Money.

8

on second thought...

silence.

Sun Nov 12, 2006 at 09:14:42 PM EST

5.00 (astute, astute)

Waiting for Godot has more of a ring to it.  

Rumsfeld and Cheney arrive at a pre-determined country and are waiting for Victory to arrive.  They're soon joined by Bush, who claims to own Iraq, and his manservant Rove.  Bush has a chicken and eats it, throwing the bones to Rumsfeld and Cheney to make their policy.  Eventually a boy arrives to tell them that Victory won't be coming today, but certainly tomorrow.

10

^ 8

Good call.

MayorBob.

Mon Nov 13, 2006 at 07:09:05 AM EST

none

For another layer of irony, consider the fact that Samuel Beckett originally wrote the play in French.  Now, imagine Bush, Cheney, et al performing the original version.  Mon dieu!

Illegitimi non carborundum.

4

Eye of the beholder

Lou.

Sun Nov 12, 2006 at 01:16:51 PM EST

none

Even though it will never happen, I would love to see that son of a bitch impeached and then dragged down Pennsylvania Ave by strands of Christo's saranwrap.

It's the end of the world as we know it, and I feel fine

7

wait, wait, don't tell me...

silence.

Sun Nov 12, 2006 at 09:03:33 PM EST

none

It's the "Scream", right?

14

Not art, but poetry

3fingerspointback.

Thu Nov 16, 2006 at 03:27:52 PM EST

none

We have a new type of rule now.  Not one man rule or rule of aristocracy or plutocracy, but of small groups elevated to positions of absolute power by random pressures and subject to political and economic factors that leave little room for decision.  They're representatives of abstract forces who've reached power through surrender of self.

The Iron-Will Dictator is a thing of the past.  There will be no more Stalins, no more Hitlers.  The rulers of this most insecure of all worlds are rulers by accident, inept, frightened pilots at the controls of a vast machine they cannot understand, calling in experts to tell them which buttons to push.

-William S. Burroughs, Dead City Radio

(is 3fingerspointback)

This story: 18 comments (5 from subqueue)
Post a Comment