The Art Of War -- Iraqi Style
MayorBob.
Posted to Politics on Sun Nov 12, 2006 at 09:11:58 AM EST (promoted by port1080). RSS.
"War is hell" is the line attributed to General William T. Sherman, uttered as his Union forces advanced on the sea to explain the devastation wrought to the Georgia countryside along the way. Had anyone asked Robert E. Lee, leading the Confederate forces, if he agreed with Sherman, they might have gotten an answer in the affirmative -- "It is well that war is so terrible, or we should grow too fond of it." More recently, the president's mom Barbara Bush described war as "not nice." Most of us, living in states believing in civilian control of the military would endorse former French Prime Minister Georges Clemenceau's observation that "war is much too serious a matter to be entrusted to the military." Following the latest explanation of the state of things in Iraq by a general in Iraq, we might want to amend Clemenceau's statement to add: "war is too serious a matter to be explained by the military."
Just when you thought you had heard the stupidest, most insensitive comparison of what's going on over in Iraq to anything else, along comes US Army Major General William Caldwell, spokesperson of the Central Command to compare the carnage and bloodshed taking place in Iraq as "a work of art." The last time Caldwell was featured in the media was when the death of Abu Musab al-Zarqawi was being reported. That was replete with video shots of the airstrikes which killed al-Zarqawi along with a nice head shot of the dead terrorist. But this time, Caldwell didn't have any back up videos or pictures to entertain the press so he decided to wax eloquent:
"Every great work of art goes through messy phases while it is in transition. A lump of clay can become a sculpture. Blobs of paint become paintings which inspire."Coming as it did a full four months since Caldwell effusively remarked that "the days of Zarqawi are over" observing that "now Iraqis from their neighborhoods to the halls of their government can rejoice and take great pride in what has been accomplished by both them and the coalition forces in eliminating that threat." That's four full months of bloodshed and misery, suffered by the Iraqi public and US forces in country - four months during which 350 coalition soldiers have given up their lives and between 5,700 and 6,100 Iraqi civilians have been killed. One wonders what sort of work of art, Major General Caldwell has in mind.
That's exactly the sort of question which occurred to two Democratic US Senators. Carl Levin of Michigan said he might be able to see the comparison if things "were moving in the right direction" but, by "Central Command's own portrayal" they're clearly not, in Levin's estimation. Jack Reed of Rhode Island (a West Point graduate) observed "West Point was never recognized for its fine-arts program" and agreed with Levin that the numbers and the news indicate we're "losing the initiative." Time for you to play art critic and, taking what you know and feel about the war in Iraq, come up with your candidate for the artistic expression which you feel comes closest to describing our Iraq adventure.
< Murder, What Murder? Nothing To See But Us Innkeepers Playing Ostrich.
The Trick Was Coming As A Suicide Bomber. The Treat Was Posing With The University President. >
