Business

Let's Have A Rebate Debate

MayorBob.

Posted to Business on Thu Dec 28, 2006 at 06:58:43 PM EST (promoted by port1080). RSS.

Most of us have been there.  You went out and purchased your wireless, Hi-Def, digital Ramalaminator and paid (US)$250 for it.  But wait, if you match up the receipts with the bar code, fill out the paperwork and mail it into Ramalaminator Inc. within the next two weeks, you'll get $100 back in a rebate!  Sounds like a deal, so you buy the thing with the best of intentions of taking advantage of the manufacturer's largesse.  But there's a dark side to the bright prospect of getting money back, of course - dissatisfiers like lost receipts, taking too long to claim a rebate, the glacial pace of the postal system, glitches in the rebate process, even dishonesty on the part of the manufacturer.  All these things add up to a feeling that rebates aren't really worth what retailers make them out to be.  They also leave the buying public with questions of why can't manufacturers just drop the prices on the stuff they sell and save us all from rebate hell?

One complaint customers have regarding rebates is the disingenuous way they are marketed.  Case in point, the price after rebate is listed in big bold letters on the store shelf, while the price you'll be paying at the register isn't as boldly displayed.  But, you've already bitten into the concept of buying the thing and you just want to get out of the store and home to set up the Ramalaminator, so you pay the full price.  After all, you got the receipt and the rebate forms, what could go wrong?

You might wait too long to begin filling out the form.  You might have tossed the receipt or the package with the original bar code on it.  But, if you're lucky enough to have done this, you send off your multiple rebates to several different manufacturers.  Now, you have run into the problem of keeping track of them.  Voila, there are tools and products available to help you keep track of rebates.

This is when you enter rebate limbo.  You've been waiting forever for your checks to come in and so you have to call the manufacturer.  This will either expedite your rebate check (if you define expediting getting it two months after purchase) or a sour stomach from talking to a customer service functionary.  Examples of rebates gone wrong aren't difficult to find seeing as how they tend to be legion.

With the opportunity high for customer dissatisfaction so high, one wonders why companies don't just discontinue offering them.  Part of it might be because the rebate redemption rate is so low - 20 percent.  However, that rate is based on total sales - a fairer statistic would be the redemption rate for incremental sales (the rate for items bought by customers because a rebate was offered).  That rate works out to about 68 percent.  Thus, it means that a lot of customers are taking the time to send in the rebate forms after all.  The potential for dissatisfaction being what it is has led Office Max to opt out of mail-in rebates last year.  Best Buy has announced they will discontinue the practice in 2007.

Tags: edited by Port1080, written by MayorBob, business, rebates (all tags)

This story: 7 comments (2 from subqueue)
Post a Comment
2

Truth in Advertising

ilsa.

Thu Dec 28, 2006 at 07:44:13 PM EST

5.00 (astute)

I'd like to see a law (since we clearly can't trust businesses to regulate themselves, duh) saying that the rebate price cannot be printed in a font that is larger than the up-front costs.  Ideally, the ad should have to list the rebates as well.  That way at least Joe Average will know that computer is $1099 out the door without the $200 in rebates, $70 of which he doesn't qualify for.

7

Re: Let's Have A Rebate Debate

SlyBaldGuy.

Sun Dec 31, 2006 at 06:10:18 PM EST

5.00 (astute)

Most people don't realize that rebates pay for themselves 100 fold.  This is because marketing companies that offer the rebates actually use the information you submit to them to sell to other marketers.  It's exactly like when you go to the mall and see a raffle to win a car.  That one car will earn the marketing company 10's of millions of dollars!  If you value your privacy, don't  send in for rebates.  Or, if you can't help it, have them send your check to an alternate address other than your living address.

3

Re: Let's Have A Rebate Debate

housewife2000.

Thu Dec 28, 2006 at 09:12:22 PM EST

4.50 (informative, informative)

I used to work for a rebate processing center, and we new every little trick to keep from sending you the check. The biggest issue we had with many rebates was not on our side, however, but on the manufacturers or 'rebate suppliers' side. Almost all rebates are based on a 'while supplies last' method. Most people will not even mail a rebate in, so the retailer figures that it needs to have funds to cover, say, twenty percent of it's actual product. This is normally fine, but when you have an especially large rebate near the holiday (say any cell phone rebate) the need almost always outstrips the supply. The processing center rarely knows what the supply is, until we are notified, after telling many people over the phone that their rebate would be sent out in a week, that there were no more.
It doesn't matter when you mail a rebate, how much postage you have on the envelope, how many times you have double/triple checked that every needed peice is there and that the information is complete, you still only stand about a ten percent chance of actually getting the check.

4

^ 3

Re: Let's Have A Rebate Debate

MayorBob.

Thu Dec 28, 2006 at 10:29:05 PM EST

none

Ever since I lost my first rebate battle some twenty years ago over a stereo system that promised $50 back from the $500 sticker price, I have never even bothered in factoring "there's a rebate" into my buying decision.  I certainly never bothered wasting the time to fill out the forms and enclose any receipts or records.  If I wasn't positive that I was going to be getting the best value for what I was buying, I wouldn't buy what was on the shelf at the time.

I had a friend of mine who bought a Singer PC many moons ago (yes, the same company which makes sewing machines sold computers).  He was conned into buying because of a $150 rebate.  So he sent the forms and receipts in and waited and waited and waited.  Finally, he did get his rebate ... sort of.  Singer sent him a "rebate certificate" good for $150 worth of "valuable Singer products."  

Illegitimi non carborundum.

1

Some make it easier than others...

port1080.

Thu Dec 28, 2006 at 07:02:59 PM EST

none

Staples has a very nice rebate system - you don't even have to mail anything in, you can do it all online by entering the UPC code into their website. I don't mind rebates like this, or even ones that require you to send in a form - as long as it's fairly simple. While I would prefer to just get the deal upfront, if they'll give me a bigger deal through a mail in rebate than they otherwise could, I'm glad to take it. So far I've gotten paid for every mail-in rebate that I've remembered to send in...but I will admit that I've forgotten to do a few (usually the low value $4 or $5 ones...sometimes they just don't seem worth the effort).

5

^ 1

Don't I feel like a dunce...

port1080.

Fri Dec 29, 2006 at 09:28:31 AM EST

none

After saying all that, I just checked the status of two rebates I submitted a few weeks ago (for a Netgear wireless router and a wireless network card) and found one of them was declined because I "sent a copy of the UPC code instead of the original." I would accept that as a valid problem (after all, rebate fraud is common), but the rebate required that you send a copy. There were two rebates - one was a $30 rebate for purchasing the router, and the other was a $20 rebate on the network card that was only valid with purchase of the router. Therefore you had to send in the router's UPC to get the rebate on the network card, and the router's UPC for its own rebate. The instructions on the rebate form very specifically said that copies were OK for the router rebate, but that you should send the originals for the network card rebate (and that's what I did). Imagine my surprise when I checked online to find that my documentation was invalid.... So I called the rebate company and the experience was actually fairly pleasant (other than the fact that they clearly use cheap IP telephone connectivity - our connection kept dropping out from time to time) and the woman I talked to authorized both rebates. Their online status page now claims that both checks are in the mail - but perhaps now I'll believe it when I receive it.

6

No scare stories here

gerrymander.

Fri Dec 29, 2006 at 10:48:54 AM EST

none

I don't usually shop for items with rebates, so it's kind of a surprise that I've sent in for as many as I have. Over the past two years, I've sent in for five, all from items purchased while traveling for business. (When the boss says, "we need this," we get it.) A few were through the Staples rebate website port1080 mentioned above, but three were by mail. All came through within eight weeks with no trouble.

This story: 7 comments (2 from subqueue)
Post a Comment