Media

Word. The Media Is A Joke.

MayorBob.

Posted to Media on Wed Dec 06, 2006 at 10:36:08 AM EST (promoted by port1080). RSS.

If it isn't a joke, perhaps the joke is on the media.  Because, for the second year in the past three, one of the leading lights in the business of reporting fake news has been named the "Media Person of the Year."  Steven Colbert was the winner of this year's title, succeeding 2005's winner, Anderson Cooper of CNN.  Jon Stewart of The Daily Show, was the winner in 2004.

Okay, it's not a Pulitzer or anything, but it's an online selection sponsored by the online media watching web site iwantmedia.com.  Ten media types were nominated for the honor and the winner emerged from a weeklong internet poll.  Colbert's competition included Rupert Murdoch, Katie Couric, youtube founder Chad Hurley, Google CEO Eric Schmidt, NBC CEO Jeff Zucker, megablogger Arianna Huffington, former Viacom CEO Thomas Freston, bubbly cooking phenom Rachael Ray, and former LA Times editor Dean Baquet.

Colbert first came to public notice as one of The Daily Show's regular correspondents.  In 2005, he left The Daily Show to begin his own fake news broadcast show The Colbert Report where he quickly set the tone as a satirical, cable news pundit awfully reminiscent of Bill O'Reilly or Sean Hannity.  But it was his remarkable performance at the White House Correspondents Association Dinner in April of this year which put him on the media map.  One media pundit said Colbert "unplugged the Bush myth machine -- and left the clueless D.C. press corps gaping."  And the New York Times Frank Rich referred to the performance as a "cultural primary" and "the defining moment" of the 2006 midterm elections.  Prior to being named "Media Person of 2006" Colbert was named to Time magazine's 100 most influential people in 2006.

So, what should all of this tell us?  Is the media really just superfluous fun filtered through the eye of a former sketch comic?  Or do we laugh too long and find the outlandish quirk in our daily news at the expense of sober and thoughtful reporting of events which should matter to us?  Are Stewart's and Colbert's shticks on the verge of getting old or are they the wave of the future?

Tags: edited by Port1080, media, Steven Colbert, Jon Stewart, satire, fake news, written by MayorBob (all tags)

This story: 14 comments (3 from subqueue)
Post a Comment
1

Changing Tastes

uncarved block.

Wed Dec 06, 2006 at 12:10:03 PM EST

5.00 (interesting)

   I was a big fan of The Daily Show for a while, through the 2004 elections and into the beginning of this year. The problem with any good comedian is that after you get see the routine for a while, you don't need the actual comic so much-- just flip on CNN and listen, and do your own version of MST3K. On a guess, Stewart is even getting a bit tired of it, or at least of doing his Bush imitation and getting cheap laughs. Given the sketchiness of his earlier career, though, I can't blame the guy for hanging on to a meal ticket even when it's no longer exciting.
   The Colbert Report . .  have you ever had an idea that was really funny in theory but not so much in execution? On a tangent, one example I can offer is Dread Zeppelin-- sometimes they're a lot of fun, but often they're so close to the original that you want to throw on Led Zep. That's how I feel about this show. Sure, a tone parody of Fox News sounds like a good idea, but when I really want to laugh at Bill O'Reilly, I just flip on Fox. (For one thing, Bill has fewer constraints, as he doesn't have to turn everything into a punchline-- it just turns out that way.) Maybe I'll give Colbert another shot, but really, can he hold a candle to Hugh Hewitt?
    As for Colbert's speech; I love C-SPAN, but have serious doubts whether anything broadcast on it can be said to have changed an election. Sure, it was great fun if you hated W, but did it really change any minds? I have my doubts*. If nothing else, it was depressing to think that there had been nothing like it before the 2004 elections, when Bush's name was actually on the ballot, instead of only there by proxy.

   *Tom Lehrer, asked about the influence of his political tunes, said, "It's not even preaching to the converted . . it's titillating the converted", and noted that the satirical Berlin cabarets of the 30s did so much to stop the rise of Hitler. All those reporters and insiders who were discomfited for one night by Colbert woke up the next day and continued on as before, from what I could tell.

Ex ignorantia ad sapientiam; e luce ad tenebras

3

^ 1

Re: Changing Tastes

MayorBob.

Wed Dec 06, 2006 at 03:23:51 PM EST

none

I was wondering what someone dropped into Frank Rich's coffee the day he labeled the Colbert speech a defining moment -- especially of the midterm elections which were held a full six months after this "defining moment."

That's not to discount the real reach and effect which Stewart and Colbert have had on the media over the past couple of years.  It's telling that as recently as a year ago, a substantial number of college-aged people were quite proud about listing "The Daily Show" as their main source of information about the world around them.  I know, it might be due to some sort of college-aged deep and abiding sense of hipness and self deprecation and I'm sure they get a lot of their info from other sources, like MTV News, youtube, or tmz.com.  But, it's also perhaps telling (and sad really) that there is anything approaching a buzz regarding having Jon Stewart and Steven Colbert as a political ticket in 2008.

I find myself not watching "The Daily Show" beyond the second segment much and hardly ever watch the interview section.  But, perhaps that's because I consider the show to be entertainment and those portions of the program devoted to the interview just doesn't seem to be entertaining.  I've watched Colbert's show a few times but, like you, if I feel the need to get a cheap laugh from O'Reilly or Hannity, I can just as easily tune in their shows for the yucks.

Illegitimi non carborundum.

2

Wow...

rombuu.

Wed Dec 06, 2006 at 12:47:27 PM EST

5.00 (brilliant)

...that must be some award if it previously was given to intellectual heavyweight Anderson Cooper.

4

^ 2

Re: Wow...

tomc.

Wed Dec 06, 2006 at 03:25:28 PM EST

none

Anderson was the guy who went to New Orleans to look around and tell the White House that aid wasn't being sent anywhere quick enough.

I figure that's gotta be worth at least a measly little media award.

8

Poor old Rachael Ray

Steve Urkel.

Wed Dec 06, 2006 at 06:18:35 PM EST

4.00 (funny)

How come Rachel Ray gets to have 10 shows? How many shows does this woman need? Let some other people have a show you big greedy.

"former LA Times editor Dean Baquet."

That's funny on so many levels. Rachel Ray has 15 shows and this guy can't even hold a job at a newspaper no one reads anymore.

"Katie Couric"

Is no Rachel Ray. Katie does what - half an hour a night, while RR has 19 seperate shows? What a loser. Also Rachel Ray has nicer tits than Couric.

"megablogger Arianna Huffington"

Mega? Note to awarders: an agglomeration of poop is not better than a lone pile of poop, it's worse. Also Huffington has exactly Zilcho shows of her own, while Rachel Ray has increased her show total to 26 in the time it took me to write this.

9

^ 8

Chef's delight

Lou.

Wed Dec 06, 2006 at 09:52:42 PM EST

5.00 (funny)

Well, Gord...there's no doubt she's a biscuit.  My advice:  Beat your meat 'til it's tender.

It's the end of the world as we know it, and I feel fine

5

Perspective

tomc.

Wed Dec 06, 2006 at 03:27:43 PM EST

none

Arianna Huffington is hotter than Stephen Colbert.

6

^ 5

Re: Perspective

rombuu.

Wed Dec 06, 2006 at 04:14:04 PM EST

none

I'd let her made me a Gyro...

...she is Greek, right?

7

^ 5

Re: Perspective

MayorBob.

Wed Dec 06, 2006 at 04:14:49 PM EST

none

And Katie Couric is a lot perkier than Colbert.

Illegitimi non carborundum.

10

These comments...

permazorch.

Mon Dec 11, 2006 at 03:12:46 PM EST

none

are making me hungry!

----- The earth may fail, but we will quiver

This story: 14 comments (3 from subqueue)
Post a Comment