Etcetera

He's Knut (That Rhymes With Cute). Question Being, Is He Too Cute To Shoot?

MayorBob.

Posted to Etcetera on Sun Mar 25, 2007 at 06:49:05 AM EST (promoted by port1080). RSS.

Knut, the Berlin Zoo's polar bear cub, is one cute animal.  He's so cute and lovable that he's become the main attraction at the zoo and an object of adoration for Germans.  That adoration deepened due to the fact that his twin brother died shortly after birth, Knut's mother rejected him, and he's been hand raised by zoo personnel since.  Now he's just taken his inaugural public walk and the oohs and ahs are flying.  One woman, who has been following Knut's progress since birth expressed thankfulness that zoo authorities didn't follow the advice of one animal activist and have Knut killed.

Gott in Himmel!  Kill Knut?  An animal activist said this?  What is wrong with this picture?  Frank Albrecht is the animal activist and, yes, he suggests the appropriate thing to do with Knut is give him the needle.  Because Knut has been rejected by his natural mother and he is being bottle fed by zoo personnel, "it is a blatant violation of animal welfare laws."  Albrecht claims the bear will develop behavioral disorders and his advice is that "the zoo must kill the bear."  What has Albrecht, and a few other activists, upset is they don't believe the zoo should have stepped in after his mother spurned him.  What they believe the Berlin zoo is raising is a very large predator which will likely not mix well with other polar bears once he reaches adulthood.

Wolfram Graf-Rudolph, director of the Aachen Zoo, believes Knut shouldn't have been hand raised, "I don't consider it appropriate for the species that the little polar bear is being raised on a bottle."  However, Knut is too old to destroy now but someone at Berlin "should have had the courage to put him to sleep much earlier."  But, that decision wasn't taken and everyone (other than Albrecht and a few others) believe Knut "deserves to live."  It should be noted that, while Germany has some of the toughest animal protection laws in Europe, nothing in them prohibits humans from stepping in to save newborn animals who will one day grow into giant predators.  Besides, according to bear experts, Knut is a wild animal and "you can't domesticate a wild animal" and, as far as him not mixing well with other adult bears, "he is programmed to be a solitary animal."    

Tags: edited by port1080, Written by MayorBob, animals, zoos (all tags)

This story: 7 comments (2 from subqueue)
Post a Comment
1

the beef with veal

gerrymander.

Sun Mar 25, 2007 at 01:08:05 PM EST

none

Do you ever get the idea that animal rights activists are only interested in being ornery? I mean, think about it: the objection here is that an animal has been raised being fed unnaturally, and therefore should be killed. But "raised being fed unnaturally" pretty much describes the entire production system behind foie gras and veal, two other bugbears of those same groups. If the proper action is to kill animals so treated, then why object to the farms for doing so?

2

^ 1

AN animal activist

Lou.

Sun Mar 25, 2007 at 01:23:16 PM EST

none

animal rights activists

Activists - plural.  In context from your comment plural construed as many.

Activist - singular as in one guy wants the bear killed.  One other thought the bear should have been killed right from the get-go, but says the bear is out of the bottle so to say, so let the little  feller live.  I guess one and a half is kinda plural.

It's the end of the world as we know it, and I feel fine

4

^ 1

Re: the beef with veal

pO157.

Sun Mar 25, 2007 at 02:01:20 PM EST

none

Do you ever get the idea that animal rights activists are only interested in being ornery? I mean, think about it: the objection here is that an animal has been raised being fed unnaturally, and therefore should be killed. But "raised being fed unnaturally" pretty much describes the entire production system behind foie gras and veal, two other bugbears of those same groups. If the proper action is to kill animals so treated, then why object to the farms for doing so?

Seriously! And if they want to open up a can of "raised being fed unnaturally" why don't they say something about the food processing our meals go through? Why don't they go out and eat like cave people used to do back in the day and avoid the Bugaboo that is supermarkets and food stores?

I don't own a gun; my ancestors were Quakers!

5

^ 1

Re: the beef with veal

rEvolution inAction.

Sun Mar 25, 2007 at 03:25:23 PM EST

none

I gotta say I don't get them at all. Calling for the execution of some animal doesn't make much sense. Now they are saying it's too old to kill.. I don't understand that at all.. if it was okay to kill it before, why would it not be okay to kill it now?

Tipping Sacred Cows

3

Germans don't watch PBS

Lou.

Sun Mar 25, 2007 at 01:33:19 PM EST

none

Maybe they should?   At least Albrecht should.   The Denver Zoo raised two orphaned polar bear cubs, Klondike and Snow and now they're still doing well in their new home at SeaWorld (scroll down)

It's the end of the world as we know it, and I feel fine

6

Bear with me

Steve Urkel.

Mon Mar 26, 2007 at 04:32:42 PM EST

none

I can relate to this bear, because I too was rejected by my mother, and the foster parents that raised me often kept me in a cage. A local priest objected to this. He was convinced I was the anti-christ, and wanted me to be put to sleep. Thankfully, no one listend to him. Maybe some day years from now this bear will escape from the zoo and track down, kill, and eat this Albrecht bastard. That's what I did to the priest, and it's one of the smartest things I ever done do. The end.

7

Re: He's Knut (That Rhymes With Cute)...

socky.

Mon Mar 26, 2007 at 04:58:46 PM EST

none

oh now I guess this would really annoy some animal rights activists*, but here goes. Polar bears are variously considered potentially threatened, endangered, or maybe sort of possibly endangered. Knut is lovely, but I don't care so much about him as about there being polar bears at all. More bears is more - and more varied - bear DNA, is good by me. I know you could get Knut's DNA and then off him, but that seems hugely wanton. Give Knut the chance of a few shags, and us the chance of a few more bears. Please?

*because I am advocating keeping an individual animal in a nightmare of unnaturalness, so I and other people can get a warm feeling about there still being bears in general. But I really really want there to always be polar bears. It is all about me.

This story: 7 comments (2 from subqueue)
Post a Comment