Etcetera

The Hero's Dead But The Controversy Lives On

MayorBob.

Posted to Etcetera on Wed Mar 28, 2007 at 08:08:08 AM EST (promoted by port1080). RSS.

The story of Pat Tillman is not yet over.  Although the man has been dead and buried for close to three years, the controversy surrounding him continues to live on.  The military has just released its latest version of what happened to Tillman and they are hoping this will be the end of it.  However, the Tillman family doesn't believe the final word has been written just yet.

The story of Pat Tillman initially seemed something from a Hollywood script.  Professional football player gives up lucrative career to answer the call of duty and fight terrorists as an Army Ranger.  Within two years of joining the Army he dies heroically under enemy fire and is awarded the Silver Star for valor.  But, if Tillman's story is a Hollywood script, it's like Rambo as told by Murphy.  As it turns out, Tillman didn't die as a result of enemy fire; he was killed by friendly fire.  The Tillman family says the Army has been covering up the facts of this case since day one and continue to do so.  The Tillman affair has been investigated five times and punishments have been dished out for what happened on the ground in Afghanistan in 2004.  But the Tillman family is still waiting for a version of what happened after Tillman's death that makes sense and calls higher ups in the chain of command to accountability.  And that, they say, has not been done yet.

What the military has done is release the latest version (pdf doc) of events.  In this version, blame does get placed with higher ups, including Lt. Gen. Philip Kensinger, former commander of Special Forces.  Acting Army Secretary Pete Geren said, "we as an Army failed in our duty" and promised that the Army will address all the issues presented in the report.  Another Pentagon spokesperson expects more disciplinary measures to be taken against "any and all" found to be responsible for the reporting cock up.  The report went on to say there didn't appear to be any crime or negligence involved in Tillman's death.

Congressman Mike Honda (D - CA) who called for an investigation soon after the Army admitted to the mix up said that Secretary Geren's press conference "raised more questions than it answered."  Honda was joined in his skepticism about this issue being put to bed by the Tillman family.  During an NPR interview, Tillman's mother, Mary, said they are definitely not done with it.  She accuses the military of continuing to lie about her son's death. She claims responsibility shouldn't end with Lt. Gen. Kensinger, pointing to Defense Secretary Rumsfeld as a "consummate micromanager" who needed Tillman to be a hero to "sell the war."  She claims the Army refuses to locate an after action report filed by an officer soon after her son died.  She was told the Army can't release the report because "it isn't signed."  She also said that, at one point when the family was being briefed, an official accused them of "being abusive" of the military.  She said:

"I wouldn't have wanted to have been them ... we were extremely rude to them, but they ... were just lying."

Tags: edited by Port1080, written by MayorBob, Pat Tillman, military, friendly fire, cover up, Afghanistan (all tags)

This story: 5 comments (2 from subqueue)
Post a Comment
1

Re: The Hero's Dead But The Controversy Lives On

Thalia.

Wed Mar 28, 2007 at 07:23:26 PM EST

4.00

I'm curious how many other soldiers had their deaths misreported.  The only reason this is still a story is because Pat Tillman is a well-known sports figure.  If this had been some 19-year-old guy from Missoula, would it ever have come out that he was shot in a friendly fire incident?

This is not a mix-up.  This is deliberate misreporting of the facts by the military to hide their own errors.  I expect that here, as in the Abu Ghraib scandal, if heads roll they will be the low-level folks who tend to end up with all of the blame and none of the loyalty from the higher ups.

Thalia

4

^ 1

Re: The Hero's Dead But The Controversy Lives On

MayorBob.

Wed Mar 28, 2007 at 11:06:58 PM EST

5.00 (informative, brilliant)

There's probably no way of knowing the answer to your initial question but, I'm inclined to think friendly fire (a ghastly term if there ever was one) doesn't account for that many combat deaths.  But, from my experience in Vietnam, if you were engaged by the enemy in a fire fight and you got hit or killed, it was assumed you got that way from an enemy bullet.  It wouldn't surprise me if some combat deaths listed as enemy fire were actually friendly fire, but in the heat of a fire fight not everyone has the ability to cooly survey the scene and tell if the guy next to you bought it from one of theirs or ours.  And, cleaning up after a fire fight usually involves packing the dead bodies away in body bags and medevacing the wounded to a field hospital.

Having said that, this case stinks to high heaven.  First of all, because Tillman was, as you point out a bit more famous than the average trooper, the circumstances of his death had resonance beyond the battlefield.  From my reading of what has been printed about this, the Army knew early on that he had been killed by one of us and, call me cynical, but when the brass got notified their poster boy (not disparaging Tillman but I'm sure that's what they thought about him) was dead, I'm sure the PR machine went into overdrive on this.  Tillman was no average soldier -- he was an icon -- and we can't have our icons killed in some mundane, stupidass manner.  He had to have died a hero's death. I'm not sure I agree totally with Mrs. Tillman that Rummy rode herd on this one but I'm sure he was satisfied at the prospect of having a hero to lay on his shield to sell the war, so he wasn't liable to question the initial version of what happened.  Besides, the Army is not loaded with Rambos -- lone, solitary heroes capable of whipping entire regiments singlehandedly -- it's loaded, especially in its officer ranks with eager beaver followers looking to please their superior officers.  You see, before you get the opportunity to lead in the military you must demonstrate you have a slavish devotion to following orders.  So when the word of Tillman's death in a enemy firefight went up the chain of command, when the order to give him the Silver Star, there was little resistance coming down the chain of command to correct the record.

The people who were involved in Tillman's death apparently have received whatever discipline the Army is going to dish out for fucking up big time when they ended up killing him.  Lt Gen Kensinger has already retired and I guess the Army could reduce his retired rank a star or two and probably a few other general officers will lose a star or be forced to resign, but the system is structured so that, when things get screwed up, usually it's a few small fry who get the shaft and everyone agrees to learn from this ... until the next time, of course.

Illegitimi non carborundum.

2

^ 1

Re: The Hero's Dead But The Controversy Lives On

thefadd.

Wed Mar 28, 2007 at 07:56:26 PM EST

none

I'm curious how many other soldiers had their deaths misreported.

Every single one since they're not allowed to show the caskets on television anymore.

escalators never fail; they just become stairs

3

^ 2

Re: The Hero's Dead But The Controversy Lives On

Thalia.

Wed Mar 28, 2007 at 08:57:46 PM EST

5.00 (informative)

There is no prohibition on showing caskets on TV.  They don't let reporters go to the planes that fly the caskets home, nor do they let them go to military bases to cover the homecoming of the caskets.  But if the media cared even a fraction as much about covering dead soldiers as they do about covering celebrities, they certainly could film individual soldiers' funerals, and caskets.  Heck, with a telephoto lens they could probably even take pictures of the caskets being unloaded from the military planes.

Thalia

This story: 5 comments (2 from subqueue)
Post a Comment