Media

Imus Suspended Amid Outrage

pO157.

Posted to Media on Wed Apr 11, 2007 at 07:59:14 AM EST (promoted by port1080). RSS.

On April 4th, in regards to the Rutgers Female Basketball team: "Man, they got tattoos, That's some nappy-headed hos there, I'm going to tell you that now."

...and with that radio entertainer Don Imus found himself suspended by MSNBC and CBS for two weeks (the suspension will not begin until 4/16 as Mr. Imus was scheduled to run a telethon benefit for sudden infant death syndrome and MSNBC and CBS do not wish to hurt that cause).

Despite repeated apologies starting two days later,  appearing on Al Sharpton's radio show to smooth over the whole affair, and planned personal discussions with the basketball team he referred to, Sharpton and Jesse Jackson, among others, continue to call for more action. They continue to demand his resignation (or failing that, that he be fired immediately from broadcasting), ponder a boycott of all his sponsors, demand legal action by the FCC against all stations that carry his program and in general, to ensure he "doesn't walk away unscathed."

Jackson also asked that this chance be taken to "desegregate the media" adding: "No black hosts on MSNBC," he said. "No black hosts on CNBC. Can we use this moment to desegregate the media?"

Tags: edited by Port1080, written by pO157, Don Imus, FCC, MSNBC, CBS, Al Sharpton, Jesse Jackson, racism, media, radio, Rutgers University (all tags)

This story: 63 comments (6 from subqueue)
Post a Comment
3

Hitting Imus Where It Hurts.

MayorBob.

Wed Apr 11, 2007 at 09:20:45 AM EST

5.00 (interesting)

Imus' mouth lost him two advertisers -- Staples and Proctor & Gamble -- with another, Bigelow Tea, rethinking advertising on his program.  Whether they manage to find advertisers willing to fill the void is anyone's guess.  On the one hand, most companies seek to avoid being connected with controversies of this sort.  On the other hand, the show is probably getting higher ratings this week while Imus is deep into his humble pie routine awaiting his suspension.

Look, Jimmy the Greek lost his job when he came out with his quaint and curious notions about racial breeding policies of antebellum Dixie.  Tom Brookshier lost his job for his casual observation that the composite IQ score of one college basketball squad didn't approach three digits.  And Al Campanis lost his job over his assertion that blacks "didn't have the necessaries" to properly manage a sporting squad.  So, why is a two week suspension deemed to be that much to pay for what Imus said?  I'm also wondering what the rationale might be for those who voted "yes" in the poll that Imus' apology is enough.

And even this morning, in the middle of one of his mumbling and stumbling attempts to atone for things, Imus let it be known that he still doesn't really get it.  One of the points of this whole media drama is that Imus dissed the Rutgers squad on more than one level.  There was that "nappy-haired" racial observation and then there was that "ho" sexist thing.  So, this morning Imus is mentioning that one of the people who reads the sports two or three times an hour during his show wasn't there last week.  And a good thing also because this sports reader is also the "voice of Rutgers football" and Imus was glad he wasn't tarnished by association with the remark.  Then he went on to say how odd it was that anyone could think the remark was all that serious when "the voice of Rutgers football" was a member of his show and his presence demonstrates how fervent the Imus show crew was about support of "all the Rutgers athletic programs."  And, I'm wondering if he gets the irony of trying to sugarcoat what he's done in arbitrarily and gratuitously insulting a women's sports achievement by touting the fact that he knows someone who broadcasts a men's sports event.  I mean it doesn't even rise to the level of "some of my best friends are (insert gender/race/ethnicity/religion)" remark.

Illegitimi non carborundum.

14

^ 3

Re: Hitting Imus Where It Hurts.

thefadd.

Wed Apr 11, 2007 at 12:40:52 PM EST

none

Uh oh, if he loses Bigelow Tea, he's done for ;-)
lol...makes you wonder about the people at Bigelow. Staples and Proctor & Gamble drop the guy but they're still "thinking about it." They must have become hardened at by the experience of multiple Rob Scheider movies carrying their name.

It is easy to buy small plaster models of what you think life is like.

26

^ 3

Perhaps I'll be tossing gas on the fire here...

pO157.

Wed Apr 11, 2007 at 04:41:46 PM EST

none

So, why is a two week suspension deemed to be that much to pay for what Imus said?  I'm also wondering what the rationale might be for those who voted "yes" in the poll that Imus' apology is enough.

Well, I think the two week suspension coupled with the humiliation, loss of advertising support he now has to endure and the damage to his reputation is enough. Was it offensive? Sure. Was it stupid. Yep. Is it worse than the garbage that gets spewed across the music channels on the radio now? I don't think so. Why not fire those venerated artists first?

My initial reaction when I first heard about this and saw who was in front of the cameras most about it was that Imus' words and apology couldn't have been nearly as bad as some of the other things those who were calling for his ouster have done and still have yet to apologize for.

Of course, now there are more respected and moderate (is moderate even the right word?) voices in the African-American community coming out saying he should be fired, so perhaps I should rethink my opinion.

Should be interesting to see how this turns out.

31

^ 26

Re: Perhaps I'll be tossing gas on the fire here..

pO157.

Thu Apr 12, 2007 at 02:10:00 PM EST

none

32

^ 31

Well, that certainly was over quick.

MayorBob.

Thu Apr 12, 2007 at 02:47:16 PM EST

5.00 (astute)

What we are seeing here is the classic case of someone who only knows how to ditch it out and knows nothing about graceful ways of having it ditched on you.

Illegitimi non carborundum.

34

^ 31

Re: Perhaps I'll be tossing gas on the fire here..

thefadd.

Thu Apr 12, 2007 at 05:22:18 PM EST

none

Down in history with Jimmy the Greek.

It is easy to buy small plaster models of what you think life is like.

12

Good lord...

rombuu.

Wed Apr 11, 2007 at 10:24:48 AM EST

5.00

what a bunch to do about nothing.  It makes me pine for the days of shark attacks, snakeheads, and Terri Schiavo on things that get media attention but really don't matter.

16

^ 12

Re: Good lord...

nmiguy.

Wed Apr 11, 2007 at 01:28:12 PM EST

5.00

But Rombuu, racism DOES matter.  People have gotten breathless and hyperbolic over Imus's stupid insensitive insult.  Yes, Imus's crime isn't even the story now. The story is the outrage, and it feeds itself.  And THAT is a big story.  Like the race riots in the 60's.  It is everybody seeing themselves as victims.  The Rutgers basketball team, Sharpton and Jackson, Imus himself, heck now everybody is feeling victimized.  Hey why can a rapper say "ho" and I can't?  Why is the word "niggaz" off limits to white guys but okay if R Kelly raps it out?

The story matters because everybody is trying to lay claim to victim status to justify their outrage, when in the end it was just a stupid shock jock insulting a bunch of strangers for no good reason.  The snowball effect, it gets bigger each day, it has not diffused with apologies and suspensions.  So in that respect, it DOES matter.  It could get worse, could get better, we don't know.  

18

^ 12

Settling Scores

uncarved block.

Wed Apr 11, 2007 at 01:47:08 PM EST

4.00 (interesting)

  Nothing? Maybe, thought that would put it in the grand tradition of the Beltway, where the little shit trips up politicians far more often than anything serious. Been going in in Washington for centuries, and I doubt it will stop soon.
   I do wonder if this is an example of another Beltway fine art, namely revenge. You step on a lot of toes (and worse) getting to the top of the media pile, and who knows how many former employees or guests are working at places like CNN and Fox, and thinking, "well, this could be the chance to drive that old asshole off the air." Dick Cheney, at least from a snippet I recall, wouldn't shed any tears if Imus never worked again. (Please note: I'm not saying Republicans are out to get him, just using Dick as one example.) Just because you're famous and help folks sell a lot of books doesn't mean you're well liked (Larry King? Jay Leno?), and slicing away advertisers is just about the only way to get the attention of media execs, from what I can tell.
   Still a goddamn ugly story all the way around.

Ex ignorantia ad sapientiam; e luce ad tenebras

15

Imus learning to speak ghetto

nmiguy.

Wed Apr 11, 2007 at 01:08:27 PM EST

5.00 (brilliant, astute, astute)

Isn't it obvious?  Don Imus was trying to broaden his experience and enrich his cultural awareness.  He has obviously purchased any of the top ten hip hop albums on the charts and learned the appropriate vernacular to describe women.  I mean if it is okay for 50 Cent to say this kind of stuff, why is it such an offense that an over the hill has-been shock jock says it?  

Why?  Because he's an easy target for the outrage.  

Jason Whitlock says it pretty well.  

We all know where the real battleground is. We know that the gangsta rappers and their followers in the athletic world have far bigger platforms to negatively define us than some old white man with a bad radio show. There's no money and lots of danger in that battle, so Jesse and Al are going to sit it out.

What I like is how Michelle Malkin has gone through the effort to post lyrics to the top rap songs out there, that many of these Rutgers Basketball players are probably listening to in their ipods.  

This is why I'm hot
Catch me on the block
Every other day
Another bitch another drop
16 bars, 24 pop
44 songs, nigga gimme what you got...

... We into big spinners
See my pimping never dragged
Find me wit' different women that you niggas never had
For those who say they know me know I'm focused on ma cream
Player you come between you'd better focus on the beam
I keep it so mean the way you see me lean
And when I say I'm hot my nigga dis is what I mean
-Mims (# 1 on the Billboard rap charts

24

^ 15

it's hard out there for a pimp

gerrymander.

Wed Apr 11, 2007 at 03:23:03 PM EST

none

What I like is how Michelle Malkin has gone through the effort to post lyrics to the top rap songs out there, that many of these Rutgers Basketball players are probably listening to in their ipods.

Change "iPod" to "dance floor" and that's the setup for a Chris Rock routine. As I recall, his punchline is the woman replying, "He ain't talkin' about me!" Because of course, "he" actually is. The only difference here is that Imus made it impossible for that convenient self-deception to take place.

25

^ 24

Re: it's hard out there for a pimp

dzetetes.

Wed Apr 11, 2007 at 03:39:16 PM EST

none

Change "iPod" to "dance floor" and that's the setup for a Chris Rock routine.

Behold!  NSFW, unless you've got headphones or a really cool workplace.

In regione caecorum, rex est luscus.

27

^ 25

Re: it's hard out there for a pimp

gerrymander.

Wed Apr 11, 2007 at 05:04:10 PM EST

none

I bow before your Web Fu, dzetetes.

30

^ 24

Re: it's hard out there for a pimp

thefadd.

Thu Apr 12, 2007 at 01:21:21 AM EST

none

that's a ridiculous assertion. we have no idea what music the nappy headed ho's on rutger's basketball team listen to.

It is easy to buy small plaster models of what you think life is like.

35

Whatever happened to....?

Steve Urkel.

Thu Apr 12, 2007 at 06:19:12 PM EST

5.00 (astute, funny)

When I run across a show that offends me, which is pretty much all the fucking time, I change the channel. Whatever happened to doing that?

"Jackson also asked that this chance be taken to "desegregate the media" adding: "No black hosts on MSNBC," he said. "No black hosts on CNBC. Can we use this moment to desegregate the media?"

I love how Jackson pretends he doesn't watch ESPN. What a poser.

55

^ 35

CNBWha?

thefadd.

Sun Apr 15, 2007 at 01:17:25 AM EST

none

*I* love how Jackson pretends anyone watches MSNBC or CNBC.

It is easy to buy small plaster models of what you think life is like.

59

^ 55

Re: CNBWha?

Steve Urkel.

Sun Apr 15, 2007 at 04:08:23 PM EST

none

True. Though CNBC's show with that James Cramer guy is amazing. An insane person trapped in a room (or is he on a sattelite, like in MST3K?), screaming and pushing buttons. Unwatchable, but amazing.

38

Re: Imus Suspended Amid Outrage

tomc.

Thu Apr 12, 2007 at 09:02:50 PM EST

5.00 (astute, astute)

I would say that Imus' comment was obnoxious.  I'm glad he apologized.  I'm glad he was suspended.  Not sure he had to get fired, but that's just arguing about degrees.

Now, what about all the other "personalities" and "artists" who say the same and much, much worse?

No, no, no. Doncha see?  THEIR insults are "au fond" a public cry against disenfranchisement.  So when THEY insult women in their music, their videos, their stage shows, their interviews, they become LIGHTENING RODS for their collective pain.

It's performance art - inviolable.

41

BREAKING

Steve Urkel.

Thu Apr 12, 2007 at 11:19:16 PM EST

4.25 (funny, astute, funny)

New Jersey Governor John Corzine was this critically injured when his motorcade crashed - en route to meeting with Imus and the Rutgers Nappy Ho's. This is what words of hate lead to. People are dying out here, man.

56

^ 41

When They Say, "Break A Leg" In NJ...

thefadd.

Sun Apr 15, 2007 at 01:21:31 AM EST

none

He's the third straight NJ governor to break his leg while in office. And he wasn't wearing his safety belt. And his accident was caused by a "special needs driver." The jokes about my home state are only beginning...

It is easy to buy small plaster models of what you think life is like.

61

^ 56

Corzine is not the third straight NJ governor ...

MayorBob.

Sun Apr 15, 2007 at 05:47:17 PM EST

4.00 (funny)

... to break his leg.  The second one turned out to be gay.

Illegitimi non carborundum.

62

^ 61

"Jogging Mishap" [!]

zyxwvutsr.

Sun Apr 15, 2007 at 06:56:15 PM EST

none

The second one turned out to be gay
The homo governor broke a leg, too:
...McGreevey suffered a broken femur in his right leg in a jogging mishap on a Cape May beach...Exactly what happened the night McGreevey suffered his injury has been a topic of speculation for years. Some allege that McGreevey was not, as he reported, with his ex-wife, but was in fact walking with Golan Cipel, the former aide McGreevey claims he had an affair with

63

^ 62

Re: "Jogging Mishap" [!]

MayorBob.

Sun Apr 15, 2007 at 07:33:34 PM EST

none

Well, it was McGreevey I was referring to Ken.  But, in honor of his proud admission that he was a "gay American" I just left it at calling him gay.

Illegitimi non carborundum.

60

^ 56

Re: When They Say, "Break A Leg"

Steve Urkel.

Sun Apr 15, 2007 at 04:14:29 PM EST

none

At least he wasn't smoking. That's all that counts these days.

I was taken aback by "special needs driver", then I remembered that mentally retarded kids at my high school drove. They can't be any more dangerous on the road than old people or teenagers who drive dangerously on purpose I guess.

4

Finally, Is Anyone Surprised?

MayorBob.

Wed Apr 11, 2007 at 09:30:00 AM EST

4.00 (informative)

I mean surprised that Imus would utter a gratuitous, stupid, and offensive remark?  It's his stock in trade.  Here's a sampler of Imus through the years.

Illegitimi non carborundum.

7

^ 4

Re: Finally, Is Anyone Surprised?

wetkarma.

Wed Apr 11, 2007 at 09:42:01 AM EST

4.00 (astute)

Maybe its because its early where I am -- but those comments strike me as marginally funny but not necessarily outre offensive. More to the point it seems to illustrate a pattern of taking potshots at everyone not juts minority. Is the man being accused of racism or just boorish behavior?

Memory is a strange bell, jubilee and knell.

5

bong hits for jesus

wetkarma.

Wed Apr 11, 2007 at 09:35:44 AM EST

4.00 (astute)

I don't get it. Is it the nappy-headed or the hos thats over the politically correct link?
Perhaps the gestalt of the two? I read the comment and translate "unattractive/poorly groomed women". Obviously if this is the correct translation, there wouldn't be an issue..so what exactly is the interpretation that is driving a conniption fit? Does anyone have the full transcript so one can see context?

While I'm at it, why is it being seen as  a black thing? Aren't there any white chixs on the team?

Is it my imagination or are the raps songs such as "Get Low" played on radio stations far more offensive? I'm a bit bewildered by all this as I assume that radio people get paid to be somewhat ribald; certainly Rush Limbaugh seems to make his spare change that way.

Memory is a strange bell, jubilee and knell.

28

^ 5

Re: bong hits for jesus

thefadd.

Wed Apr 11, 2007 at 05:24:56 PM EST

5.00 (astute)

I think it's a combination of multiple issues. First, I think it does have something to do with the fact that Rutgers lost (so there's a bit of piling on and more bad feelings in the first place) and that Rutgers is an urban school in the north east, which seems to be the current nexis of pc-ness.

As for the precise words Imus used, I do believe it's the combination that is lethal. If he'd called them all "ho" he'd have just been an ass. If he'd call them all "nappy headed," well, there's a stretch to turn that into an insult, although you could see some people trying for sure. So, in the end, he called them ho and he added on a descripter that marks them as being of a specific race. If he'd said, "black ho's" I think people would still have had a problem because the issue that arises is, ok fine they're ho's but why does he have to attach the race? The natural conclusion is that he is trying to debase their sexuality as black women. That is offensive.

Finally, they are female athletes and female student athletes at that. They've thrust themselves into the media spotlight but really only has athletes first (since their games are televised) and as students second since they still go to school. But he's not critiquing them on either of those levels. He's saying, I look at you and I don't see female athletes, I see your hair and your promiscuity. On top of this, they were a bit of a cinderella story. The media talking point all along was how spunky and hard working these women were and how much they put on the line just to come in second -- what an acheivement that was. And his reply is, you're just nappy headed ho's to me.

It is easy to buy small plaster models of what you think life is like.

6

^ 5

Re: bong hits for jesus

ms sue.

Wed Apr 11, 2007 at 09:41:20 AM EST

none

I read the comment and translate "unattractive/poorly groomed women". Obviously if this is the correct translation, there wouldn't be an issue

There most certainly would, for some of us who think that women athletes deserve better.

BTW, I'm not really picking on you, wk. Your comments just attract me. :-)

10

^ 6

Re: bong hits for jesus

wetkarma.

Wed Apr 11, 2007 at 09:54:38 AM EST

none

There most certainly would, for some of us who think that women athletes deserve better.

Seriously? Why? Isn't the fact that they are athletes indicative that they are abnormal relative to the rest of the population?  Why should women athletes get a free ride/easier time vs. other public figures subject to similar levels of ridicule.

I think I must have some serious cultural blinders on this issue, because in my mind these women are fair targets for media comment/derision. I -thought- what was going on was that the comment was somehow racial..but if its just an issue of saying some women look ugly...what the hell? I hear as much from commentators regarding the cheerleaders of the team that the home team is playing.


BTW, I'm not really picking on you, wk. Your comments just attract me. :-)

No worries. Its nice to be read ;)

Memory is a strange bell, jubilee and knell.

13

^ 10

Re: bong hits for jesus

ms sue.

Wed Apr 11, 2007 at 10:44:47 AM EST

none

Why should women athletes get a free ride/easier time vs. other public figures subject to similar levels of ridicule.

I would have the same reaction to a similar comment about any public figure.

As for the comment being racist, I think it pretty well matches the definition, regardless of Imus's intent. I also don't think it's funny to insult the players' looks. Don't you think women athletes have a bit of an extra burden in that regard? Sure, commentators undoubtedly make casual remarks about the physical attributes of male athletes, but please don't tell me that their looks or their sexual appeal or lack thereof is anywhere near the level of importance attached to women in sports.

I would agree that this is a lot of media pumping. But I think, as you wondered as well, that the racist/sexist combo here, along with the sympathy for the team, elevated this into a circus, one that will continue now that the players have said that they want to meet with Imus in private.

19

^ 13

Re: bong hits for jesus

wetkarma.

Wed Apr 11, 2007 at 02:23:39 PM EST

4.00 (interesting)


As for the comment being racist, I think it pretty well matches the definition, regardless of Imus's intent. I also don't think it's funny to insult the players' looks. Don't you think women athletes have a bit of an extra burden in that regard? Sure, commentators undoubtedly make casual remarks about the physical attributes of male athletes, but please don't tell me that their looks or their sexual appeal or lack thereof is anywhere near the level of importance attached to women in sports.

Maybe I'm just not hip with racist argot, but I still (and this after reading all too many articles while working) don't see the racism aspect. I'll agree that its mean to insult someone/anyones looks, but a lot of comedy is a bit mean spirited -- which is why many people don't like to sit in the front row at comedy shows.

I think women athletes get a far cushier ride than women scientists -- for one they get scholarships via Title IX entitlements far more easily than other women in college. I also think that as athletes, they are fair game for commentary ranging from "her drive was off because her big tits got in the way" to "Mia Hamm sure is hot with her shirt off". Female athletes might be competing for the "spirit" or "team" building experience, but sports are primarily entertainment as consumed by the masses. So just like its legitimate to call attention to the type of sneakers a player wears, its also legitimate to talk about how the player looks.

Its a visual medium selling a visual product. Hell I fully expect Vidal Sassoon to make a commercial soon featuring these athletes.

Memory is a strange bell, jubilee and knell.

21

^ 19

Re: bong hits for jesus

ms sue.

Wed Apr 11, 2007 at 03:06:01 PM EST

1.00

I think women athletes get a far cushier ride than women scientists -- for one they get scholarships via Title IX entitlements far more easily than other women in college. I also think that as athletes, they are fair game for commentary ranging from "her drive was off because her big tits got in the way" to "Mia Hamm sure is hot with her shirt off".

Cool. I didn't realize all this. Very enlightening.

Oh, and btw, since I'm one to ask questions or make comments on a more personal level all the time anyway, here's hoping you'll feel the same way one day if a daughter of yours decides to try to be an athlete.

22

^ 21

Re: bong hits for jesus

wetkarma.

Wed Apr 11, 2007 at 03:15:11 PM EST

none


Oh, and btw, since I'm one to ask questions or make comments on a more personal level all the time anyway, here's hoping you'll feel the same way one day if a daughter of yours decides to try to be an athlete.

If my daughter gets a free ride to college and as a result has to contend with radio personalities calling her a "nappy headed ho", I won't be put out. Much in the same manner if my daughter goes to a free American school (fat chance of that) and gets accused of having cooties, I still won't care.

Sure I'll pretend to be outraged and promise to "go have a talk" with Jimmy the bully (whether he be a radio personality or a 3rd grader)..but inside..honestly I don't think I'd bother mentioning it here on TnT as a story.

Memory is a strange bell, jubilee and knell.

23

^ 22

Re: bong hits for jesus

ms sue.

Wed Apr 11, 2007 at 03:21:42 PM EST

none

If my daughter gets a free ride to college and as a result has to contend with radio personalities calling her a "nappy headed ho", I won't be put out.

Actually, I wasn't referring to Imus's lame comments. I was referring to yours: I also think that as athletes, they are fair game for commentary ranging from "her drive was off because her big tits got in the way" to "Mia Hamm sure is hot with her shirt off".

If you'd be okay with that as a dad, fine. Personally, if I were a father, I'd want to deck any asshole who thought that was fair commentary.

20

^ 5

Re: bong hits for jesus

gerrymander.

Wed Apr 11, 2007 at 02:47:33 PM EST

none

Aren't there any white chixs on the team?

Assuming the team's website is up to date, there are two.

29

Let the Market Decide

pattonbt.

Thu Apr 12, 2007 at 12:52:00 AM EST

4.00 (interesting)

In my viewing of the set up comments and 'statement' itself, theres no doubt that a) it was racist, b) it was sexist and c) it was done in an attempt to 'be cool' and to shock.

As far as what happens to him, let his advertisers, listeners and stations decide.  Maybe its because I am a fan of the offensive that I simply say 'if its not your humor, turn the channel'.  Does he have a right to say those things?  Sure.  But those who pay him have a right to decide whether they will continue to give him the current platform to perform.  And if that means he is no longer given any paid platform he can still sit around in his ludicrous hats in his underwear in his apartment and spout off for eternity as he sees fit.  

So theres no 'free speech' issue here.  No one is saying Imus cant say those things.  People are saying to his employers that those comments are indicative of some nasty personal beliefs and should not be given a high profile, mainstream platform.

I cant say Ive ever heard or watched any of Imus's programs, but the snippets Ive caught over the years, being in tune enough with entertainment and pop culture, I know of him and his reputation.  Hes simply a shock jock in a huge market who's lasted long enough to get clout.  Could he be a racist?  Sure, I suspect theres a bit of that in him.  Is he an arrogant clod?  Sure.  Does he understand why his comments were offensive?  Of course.  He wouldnt have said them otherwise.  Hes not stupid.  He just didnt anticipate well enough how they would be perceived and how much 'truth' of his real feelings he left unveiled in his delivery.

I personally find the remarks hateful and since Imus didnt get my patronage anyway, hes not going to get it now.  Do I personally believe he should be fired?  Yes.  Given his stature and exposure, and the history of prior comments, theres no excuse or defense for him to employed by the mainstream media.  But if thats what his employers, enablers and fans want - so be it.  But it would be shame.

1

Re: Imus Suspended Amid Outrage

zyxwvutsr.

Wed Apr 11, 2007 at 08:29:17 AM EST

none

I know of one ho who deserves an apology.

2

^ 1

Re: Imus Suspended Amid Outrage

MayorBob.

Wed Apr 11, 2007 at 08:54:27 AM EST

none

The Daily Show made light of Ms. Zurich's plight the other day.  Something to the effect that, to belong to this team and travel to the place they arrived and not receive a gratuitous, ugly, racist insult is a slap in the face of non-nappy haired women athletes everywhere.

Illegitimi non carborundum.

8

^ 1

Re: Imus Suspended Amid Outrage

ms sue.

Wed Apr 11, 2007 at 09:42:06 AM EST

none

I don't get it.

9

^ 8

Re: Imus Suspended Amid Outrage

MayorBob.

Wed Apr 11, 2007 at 09:44:55 AM EST

4.00 (astute)

It was just Ken's way of saying Ms. Zurich certainly doesn't have nappy hair.  I guess it means he sort of agrees that Ms. Zurich remains a ho.

Illegitimi non carborundum.

11

^ 9

Re: Imus Suspended Amid Outrage

zyxwvutsr.

Wed Apr 11, 2007 at 10:10:39 AM EST

4.00 (funny)

I guess it means he sort of agrees that Ms. Zurich remains a ho
I'm sorry. Does that settle the matter?

17

^ 9

Re: Imus Suspended Amid Outrage

nmiguy.

Wed Apr 11, 2007 at 01:30:46 PM EST

4.00 (brilliant)

I'm seeing marketing opportunities here.  T-shirts that say "I'm a nappy headed ho".  They should sell like hotcakes.

33

The Fat Lady Just Finished Singing.

MayorBob.

Thu Apr 12, 2007 at 04:44:24 PM EST

none

After MSNBC pulled the plug on the simulcast of his radio show, people were speculating whether Imus would just come back after two weeks and pick up where he left off.  Well, he won't be picking up anytime soon as CBS announced it was cancelling his radio show.  Now where will Doris Kearns Goodwin and Joe Lieberman go for a shot of media spotlight?

Illegitimi non carborundum.

42

^ 33

Re: The Fat Lady Just Finished Singing.

wetkarma.

Fri Apr 13, 2007 at 09:11:53 AM EST

none

This whole case for the first time has me feeling completely disconnected from American culture. I have not seen a single article/comment which explains to me why the comment is perceived as racist. I am also bewildered why this particular sexist comment would raise such a media firestorm.

The best coverage on this story has been a Time Magazine article and even that only raises more questions than it answers.

I can't recall ever hearing Don Imus' radio show, but I do know for a fact that there are many many radio shows (Neal Boortz for example) who have commented on the looks of public women and not been terminated. I couldn't care less about Don Imus, I'm just confused as to what exactly are people objecting to.

Memory is a strange bell, jubilee and knell.

43

^ 42

Re: The Fat Lady Just Finished Singing.

ms sue.

Fri Apr 13, 2007 at 09:58:41 AM EST

none

I have not seen a single article/comment which explains to me why the comment is perceived as racist.

A non-U.S. Plastician had never heard of the word "nappy." So he seemed to sincerely question what the problem was with all this. It took a bit of explaining, but he finally understood.

What is it that you're missing about this? That question doesn't imply any agreement or disagreement with the media hoopla and/or the firing. I'm just curious how anyone can think that the inclusion of a physical attribute known to be associated with a particular race and long used in a derogatory way is anything but a racial slur.

44

^ 43

Re: The Fat Lady Just Finished Singing.

wetkarma.

Fri Apr 13, 2007 at 10:16:20 AM EST

none


What is it that you're missing about this?

The part where the term "nappy-headed" equates to being a racial slur. Maybe its because a) I didn't grow up here and b) its not as widely known as say 'nigger' but I have a completely different cultural interpretation of "nappy headed" while nevertheless being familiar with the term.

I can state as a fact that it is colloquially used in many Caribbean islands by -parents regarding their kids, as well as kids themselves regardless of race-   without any trace of racism attached to it.

Prior to your post I was under the assumption that the objectionable issue was the use of the word "ho"..now your comment has confused me even more.

Memory is a strange bell, jubilee and knell.

45

^ 44

Re: The Fat Lady Just Finished Singing.

zyxwvutsr.

Fri Apr 13, 2007 at 10:46:12 AM EST

none

You've never noticed how many African-American women spend a tremendous amount of time, effort, and money making their hair straight (that is, non-nappy)?

46

^ 45

Re: The Fat Lady Just Finished Singing.

wetkarma.

Fri Apr 13, 2007 at 10:54:17 AM EST

none


You've never noticed how many African-American women spend a tremendous amount of time, effort, and money making their hair straight (that is, non-nappy)?

Er women in general spend an inordinate amount of time on beauty efforts which seem pointless to me (high heels for example). I haven't really noticed efforts in that direction, but honestly haven't really thought about it.

Still -- over the past few years I've dyed my own hair (naturally black and straight) -- blond, red, cut it to various lengths (from down to my ass to marine style) and not once have I thought that in doing so it was somehow attempting to look like some other race/divorce myself from my own ethnicity [whatever that might be -- all things considered I don't fit neatly into any one ethnic category]

Still assuming african-women are sensitive about their hair -- what makes it racism to poke fun at that?

Memory is a strange bell, jubilee and knell.

47

^ 46

Re: The Fat Lady Just Finished Singing.

zyxwvutsr.

Fri Apr 13, 2007 at 11:08:51 AM EST

5.00 (astute)

The use of the term "nappy-headed" was clearly meant as a mocking insult. (I mean, I hope it's clear. Do you think it's reasonable to take it any other way?) I have no trouble seeing that a mocking insult that points out a racial attribute is a racial insult.

In this case the racial insult was also clearly said in jest. But that doesn't make it any less racial.

48

^ 47

Re: The Fat Lady Just Finished Singing.

wetkarma.

Fri Apr 13, 2007 at 12:09:29 PM EST

none

The use of the term "nappy-headed" was clearly meant as a mocking insult. (I mean, I hope it's clear. Do you think it's reasonable to take it any other way?) I have no trouble seeing that a mocking insult that points out a racial attribute is a racial insult.

So saying "that so blonde of her" or "that irish redhead..she's a fiery one" -- all racial insults? If yes..perhaps racial insults should be viewed separately from racism as I see no distinction that being "blonde" or "redhead" is somehow better than being nappy-headed. I've always thought that was wrong with racism was the presumption that one race was superior/inferior to another...I didn't realize that if one noted certain obvious facts whether its blondness/napypy headness then that too was a form of racism.

WK

Memory is a strange bell, jubilee and knell.

58

^ 48

Re: The Fat Lady Just Finished Singing.

zyxwvutsr.

Sun Apr 15, 2007 at 09:40:03 AM EST

none

So saying "that so blonde of her" or "that irish redhead..she's a fiery one" -- all racial insults?
No, because blonde-white or redhead-white are not generally recognized as races, but African is. (Race being mostly a social construct, of course. There are several African races, but most Americans are ignorant of that fact and therefore don't draw distinctions.) Also, "blonde" or "irish redhead" are not the insults in those examples, but the implication of low intelligence and irascible temperament.

49

^ 42

Re: The Fat Lady Just Finished Singing.

thefadd.

Fri Apr 13, 2007 at 03:17:13 PM EST

none

Imus's firing has brought me to the sad conclusion that there simply is no "there" there. My gf says she's happy it happened because white people "have gotten too comfortable" and "think they can say anything." Sorry but I thought that was the point of America. I support Barack Obama and gay marriage and I'm trying to think of a third thing liberals in America stand for today but I can't. But this Imus fiasco is nothing but a shark attack media bonanza. Hell, he'll kick back in the riviera for two months and be back on satellite radio by September. It ain't even a thing. People got pissed because he said it about kids, kids who were a cinderella story with feel good media slovenly out the ass but who lost a basketball game, so we should all feel good and sorry for them. He controverted the media talking points.

Make no mistake, this is a race issue because that's Al Sharpton up there and not Gloria Steinem. And for that reason, in my mind, it's payback. For the first time in history, black people have a modicum of power over white people. Never before in America have black people been able to make white people do something. But now Al Sharpton just has to poke his ignorant face onto TV and he can get Michael Richards or Don Imus wimpering at his feet. It's summed up precisely in the South Park episode when Jesse Jackson makes Stan's dad literally kiss his ass to apologise. For centuries, white people used language as a key instrument in their oppression of blacks. Now, society at large is coming to grips with its understanding of how wrong that was. And black leadership in America has seized that opportunity to turn language into a power grab. All they have to do is say, "we're offended" and the media tears off into a guilt trip. There doesn't have to be any basis in reality at this point.

You don't see a true leader like Bill Cosby out there calling for Imus to step down. Because he understands what a negative influence this culture of victimhood is. It leads down the path of irresponsibility and ends in the laps of confused young man like Pacman Jones who have not been empowered by their community leaders. Instead, they've been told time and again that they are victims so that those self-same leaders can exploit their own people in exchange for television time.

make it rain you nappy headed ho's

50

^ 49

Re: The Fat Lady Just Finished Singing.

MayorBob.

Fri Apr 13, 2007 at 04:45:46 PM EST

none

I think a more compelling reason for Imus losing his gig is that the money walked out on him.  When the first group of advertisers announced they were pulling out on him I thought there was a chance he might get the two week suspension lengthened to three or four.  But when just about every major advertiser on his program backed out I knew it was over for him.

As you say, Bill Cosby and many mainstream blacks were holding back refusing to join the lemmings following Jackson and Sharpton to the cliffs.  And I honestly wonder just how many blacks really and truly consider those two to be the voices of the community.  But it wasn't the black protest that broke it off in the I-Man.  As Richard Nixon once said when he was about to take a helicopter to retirement "I lost my political base of support in Congress."  Well Imus lost his economic base of support in the media.

Illegitimi non carborundum.

51

^ 50

Seconded

uncarved block.

Sat Apr 14, 2007 at 11:49:36 AM EST

5.00 (brilliant)

   I distrust this notion that Jackson and Sharpton somehow have these magic wands that can get them results. They complain a lot, but lightning only strikes once in a while-- when some other factor provides enough juice to force the issue. In this case money was an effect, but I'd argue it wasn't the cause-- no, the driving force here was sports.
   Think about it; Imus was a known factor in the media, and his backers had to know that a little flak was going to be a part of doing business. Indeed, in the modern day, a little controversy can be good business. But then ESPN started talking about the story every couple hours, and I believe these companies realized they were looking at a whole new demographic- and a huge money demographic at that- who might well take their money elsewhere if Imus stuck around. If he'd picked on some strippers, maybe some welfare moms, he'd still have a job; diss the sports media juggernaut, though, and it's no surprise he's looking at retirement.

Ex ignorantia ad sapientiam; e luce ad tenebras

52

^ 51

Re: Seconded

thefadd.

Sun Apr 15, 2007 at 01:09:23 AM EST

none

This is an extremely astute comment that has yet to be brought up in most of the conversations I've seen on this topic. My conclusion to this point was that the Rutgers team was seen as extremely sympathetic because of their youth and I had not yet thought of the fact that Imus had essentially stepped into a different arena, no pun intended. The liberal moral force of ESPN cannot be discounted in the least. They are the ratings kings of basic cable and own the satellite transponders on which a lot of other basic cable networks depend for their very life so they get to throw their weight around quite a bit.

For whatever reason, I hadn't watched ESPN at all these past two weeks so I hadn't picked up on it but I should have. They were the ones who led the charge on Tim Hardaway (which was a good thing in my mind).

It is easy to buy small plaster models of what you think life is like.

57

^ 52

Not Just ESPN

uncarved block.

Sun Apr 15, 2007 at 09:29:59 AM EST

none

   In a way, all sports became connected in a general universe a couple years after ESPN rolled around- or even more so than before- so that baseball announcers, say, feel comfortable talking about football, racing, basketball, what have you. Add on that NBC broadcasts NBA games, CBS (I think) covers the NCAA hoops finals, everyone covers football when they can, and the tons of outlets that broadcast local baseball games . . that's an awful lot of eyeballs, and a lot of money. ESPN, I'd guess, was the canary in the coal mine for the execs, who couldn't be sure Imus wouldn't turn into a repeat joke figure, like Martha Stewart or Al Gore.
   Well, that and the fact that women are still someone's daughters until they graduate college-- and any teenage boy can tell you you won't get far dissing a man's daughter. Even Zappa provoked his biggest controversies with songs like "Jewish American Princess" and "Catholic Girls", IIRC, though I'm not 100% positive about that history.

Ex ignorantia ad sapientiam; e luce ad tenebras

36

good freakin' riddance

Lou.

Thu Apr 12, 2007 at 08:43:34 PM EST

none

See yah Don...maybe next we can get rid of the rest of the lowest common denominator bullshit artists out there and maybe...JUST MAYBE start cleaning up our collective unconscious

Hah!  Who am I kidding?  All this does is allow another network with lower standards to pick Imus up.  Shit...I'm going back to bed.

It's the end of the world as we know it, and I feel fine

37

^ 36

The Phrase That Pays.

MayorBob.

Thu Apr 12, 2007 at 08:59:11 PM EST

none

Here's a shocker, early morning drive time DJ up in the Poconos gets the ax.  His offense?  He ran a contest called the "Phrase That Pays" offering cash to any listeners who would call in and say "I'm a nappy-haired ho."  He got three takers before the station management ended both the contest and his employment with the station.  Heh, maybe him and Imus can team up and start their own network.

Illegitimi non carborundum.

39

^ 37

That didn't take long

Lou.

Thu Apr 12, 2007 at 09:48:20 PM EST

5.00 (funny, funny, funny)

Here's a thought...anyone who claims to be (insert name here) In The Morning should be shot on sight.

Who are you?

I'm "Gary in the morning!"

POW POW!

This is why I don't listen to anything but my own mix cds on the way to work.  If I listened to these early rising assholes, I would be pulling out a shotgun when I got to the job.  I despair that much for humanity.

And during my drive, if I see some minivan jaggoff laughing it up, all I can do is weep 'cuz you know he's listening to "fuckface in the morning."

You know...if America's collective brow were any lower, it would be a mustache.

It's the end of the world as we know it, and I feel fine

40

^ 39

radio. suckers never play me.

Steve Urkel.

Thu Apr 12, 2007 at 11:02:03 PM EST

none

Could you share your thoughts on the 'zoo crew' format? Thank you.

53

^ 40

Re: radio. suckers never play me.

thefadd.

Sun Apr 15, 2007 at 01:13:28 AM EST

none

I can't stand talk radio from NPR to Radio America to morning shows and so on down the dial. But Mark & Brian on KLOS here in LA are almost listenable when I've exchausted all other musical options. They have a distrinctly positive outlook.

It is easy to buy small plaster models of what you think life is like.

54

^ 37

Re: The Phrase That Pays.

thefadd.

Sun Apr 15, 2007 at 01:15:34 AM EST

3.00 (informative)

Morning shows and their "contests" are dangerous things and should simply be labeled as such and left alone. I mean, Imus never killed anyone.

It is easy to buy small plaster models of what you think life is like.

This story: 63 comments (6 from subqueue)
Post a Comment