Etcetera

Honoris Causa Be Causin' Some Debate.

pO157.

Posted to Etcetera on Thu Jul 26, 2007 at 08:53:07 PM EST (promoted by 1fastdog). RSS.

The practice of institutions of higher learning passing out honorary doctorates at commencement started in the late 1470s. Since then, it has sparked debate on whether the unearned degrees cheapen the hard work of university students.

The sheepskins, which are usually awarded as Masters or Doctoral degrees, allow the honoree to receive the certificate without actually completing any of the requirements, which can be extremely rigorous for the graduate degrees. Since these degrees are awarded at commencement, the beneficiaries usually get to give a speech, even if the person and subject matter are controversial, potentially taking attention away from the students. Others raise issues of degrees for privileges or money, the fairness of selection committees meeting in secret, and other sketchy practices.

Many of those recognized include famous surgeons, educators, scientists, and the like who meet strict criteria. It is not uncommon to hear of elite members of society who are given multiple degrees from different universities. Of course, some of the recipients are not from backgrounds quite so lofty as those mentioned above, and their contribution to society may be academically somewhat negligible, or downright scary.

Then again, if you can't get the respect of a college or university to grant you that unearned PhD, perhaps you could always buy one, err, pay a "support honorarium."

Tags: written by pO157, edited by 1fastdog, education, PhD, honorary degree, degree, college, university (all tags)

This story: 4 comments (0 from subqueue)
Post a Comment
1

Re: Honoris Causa Be Causin' Some Debate.

thefadd.

Thu Jul 26, 2007 at 09:05:12 PM EST

none

Aren't all honorary degrees noted as such, though? It seems like sort of a non-issue. I guess there are going to be some people some places who will take them seriously. Still, it seems to me that they're honorary, yea look at me! and that's about it. I suppose if people wanted to be tight about it, they could restrict them to being general degrees, ie, not in anything in particular, just a whole class unto themselves. In the end, though, it's a pretty good final lesson for graduates as they sit their contemplating their three, four, five years of either hard work or cheating their way through: no matter how hard you work and how deserving you are of something, there will always be someone more powerful, more famous, more connected or simply more well heeled who can just prance in and have the same thing your having just handed to them on a silver platter.

It is easy to buy small plaster models of what you think life is like.

2

Re: Honoris Causa Be Causin' Some Debate.

rombuu.

Thu Jul 26, 2007 at 09:37:07 PM EST

none

Man, that's what I want to see... someone getting an honorary degree and going "Alight! Now I can sit for that CPA exam I've had my eye on!"

3

^ 2

Re: Honoris Causa Be Causin' Some Debate.

thefadd.

Thu Jul 26, 2007 at 11:14:50 PM EST

none

And yet, oddly, it's the perfect qualification for a sociology professorship.

It is easy to buy small plaster models of what you think life is like.

4

^ 2

Re: Honoris Causa Be Causin' Some Debate.

pO157.

Fri Jul 27, 2007 at 08:54:26 AM EST

none

I'd love to see that happen, or somebody sitting for the bar on an honorary JD. If I ever retire to one of the few states that allow people to take the bar after years of self study I would probably do it. It seems like a neat way to pass the time and we all probably look up enough law just from posting on TnTs. If I move to a state that does not allow it I'll just buy off the local college professor and get an honorary JD. Either that or ask the Archbishop of Canterbury for one.

Perhaps situations like these are why a lot of the upper level jobs (at least in the hard sciences) usually state under requirements "an earned doctorate."

This story: 4 comments (0 from subqueue)
Post a Comment