SciTech

Zero Dollars For Meds That May Soon Work Zero

thefadd.

Posted to SciTech on Sat Aug 11, 2007 at 08:37:54 AM EST (promoted by port1080). RSS.

Amid increased earnings, the Publix supermarket chain has elected to release certain antibiotics completely free to its customers with the appropriate prescription.

Tired of other rising medicine prices and banned from seeking cheaper alternatives in Canada, much of the public hailed Publix's decision. Industry leaders viewed the move as a salvo fired against Wal-Mart, who has inexorably moved into Publix's grocery market. Last year, Wal-Mart slashed prices on many of the same antibiotics to just four dollars per prescription.

The immediate question for debate that comes to mind is -- is this a gesture of good will by local grocer or two businesses competing for market share. Shockingly, the answer may be neither. Indeed, the value of antibiotics has been dropping for more than a decade. They could soon be obsolete as strains of bacteria develop immunity to those most basic and inexpensive. Will cheaper drugs just mean they become useless faster?

Tags: edited by Port1080, written by thefadd, Publix, antibiotics (all tags)

This story: 6 comments (0 from subqueue)
Post a Comment
1

Re: Zero Dollars For Meds That May Soon Work Zero

pO157.

Mon Aug 13, 2007 at 11:19:43 AM EST

none

This isn't surprising. Many generic antibiotics are made by overseas companies or cheaper suppliers, which keep the costs down, probably below a few dollars for a weeks supply. This is a good move for Publix because if each customer simply buys a few items in the grocery store they break even and every customer they steal away from other chains is a bonus for them.

As for the comment that this will increase bacterial resistance faster, I am not so sure. You will still need a doctor's prescription in order to obtain the cheap drugs from the pharmacy and that shouldn't be easy to come by, especially as the campaign to educate physicians and the public as to what requires an antibiotic and what does not takes off. The barrier to incorrect use of these drugs should not (and probably has not occurred in the past) be who can afford the drugs at the pharmacy, but rather at the physician's discretion to weed out inappropriate usage.

2

Re: Zero Dollars For Meds That May Soon Work Zero

3fingerspointback.

Mon Aug 13, 2007 at 01:03:06 PM EST

none

I don't think this will alter the effectiveness of antibiotics any more than it is already influenced by doctor's prescriptions.  It's not like they're handing out free amoxicillin next to the "take a penny" bucket.  Also, is it really so easy to conclude that universal access to an antibiotic decreases its effectiveness?  The converse is to allow people to walk around us, functioning as breeding reservoirs of billions of the bugs.  Other bugs don't use humans as their primary breeding grounds, only showing up in the body when we get splashed from the wrong puddle or bit by the wrong spider.  These germs should always be treatable with the same antibiotics, because their main breeding grounds aren't exposed to them (yet).

Also, this story reminds me of a (possibly apocryphal) story from the mid-80s--two grocers had a price war over bananas that got so fierce, after one offered its bananas for free, the other started taping pennies to every bunch.

(is 3fingerspointback)

3

^ 2

Re: Zero Dollars For Meds That May Soon Work Zero

pO157.

Mon Aug 13, 2007 at 01:52:48 PM EST

none

I would be more worried over the excessive use of antibiotics in livestock feed and on the farm (especially those also used to treat human diseases) than I would Publix giving out free scripts.

Also, is Publix really doing this for free, or simply not charging a co-pay to the consumer like Wal-Mart is? If they are still sticking the insurance company for the bill then I see their maneuver as skillfulw, but much less charitable.

4

^ 3

Re: Zero Dollars For Meds That May Soon Work Zero

thefadd.

Tue Aug 14, 2007 at 03:28:50 PM EST

none

I hadn't thought of that issue (ie, it's just the co-pay they are waiving), which is almost certainly the case. Except that if insurance companies get wind of this they might clamp down. Still, I think antibiotics are one of the most abused products out there by consumers. People don't think twice about popping them for a few days until they feel better. It seems like an issue that should be addressed at the provider level to curb people's enthusiasm for these overused drugs.

It is easy to buy small plaster models of what you think life is like.

5

^ 4

Re: Zero Dollars For Meds That May Soon Work Zero

pO157.

Tue Aug 14, 2007 at 03:47:20 PM EST

none

Seriously. Healthcare should not be reduced to the same level as my cell phone company. When I call in they say "Well, here's a free bonus feature just for taking the time to call us today." What's next? "Hey, soccer mom: Sorry it's a viral infection your kid has, but nobody leaves empty handed. So, here's a 14 day trial of Vitamin R for your husband -- thanks for popping in!"

6

^ 2

Re: Zero Dollars For Meds That May Soon Work Zero

thefadd.

Tue Aug 14, 2007 at 04:51:52 PM EST

none

functioning as breeding reservoirs of billions of the bugs

but at least they won't be superbugs.

It is easy to buy small plaster models of what you think life is like.

This story: 6 comments (0 from subqueue)
Post a Comment