Etcetera

The Smiley Face Of Death. Serial Killers Among Us Or False Theory?

MayorBob.

Posted to Etcetera on Wed Apr 30, 2008 at 12:09:54 PM EST (promoted by port1080). RSS.

The body count for serial killers is impressive. Ted Bundy is believed responsible for 35 victims. John Wayne Gacy ran up a total of 33 victims. Gary Ridgway eventually pleaded guilty to 48 murders. A couple of things connect these prolific killers: an outward appearance of normality and they managed to accomplish much of their work before anyone suspected there was a serial murderer at work. Now, there's the possibility of another monster quietly and efficiently killing as many as 40 victims thus far.

If retired NYPD detectives Anthony Duarte and Kevin Gannon are to be believed, Patrick McNeill was the first victim. The Fordham University student was found drowned in the Hudson River back in 1997. He had been drinking the night before and his death was quickly ruled a suicide. McNeill's family disputes the claim of suicide and Gannon, who caught the case, agreed to never give up on the case. What he and Duarte have established is what they believe is an 11 year pattern. They believe someone has been targeting young, male college students, drowning them and making the deaths look like a suicide or accident. According to Gannon, the pattern includes "specifically targeting a small, narrow group of individuals for murder" and leaving a smiley face drawing as a calling card.

The death trail leads away from New York City and on up to the upper Midwest. Here is a list of suspected Minnesota and Wisconsin victims Duarte and Gannon say are linked. The death of the last Wisconsin victim on that list, Lucas Homan, was the subject of a previous TnT story. This is an interactive map showing the locations of some of the deaths. Chris Jenkins is the one which changed everything for Duarte and Gannon, as his death is the only one among the many suspected victims which has been officially changed to homicide. One of the more creepier aspects of the case is that the pair is convinced the murders are a group effort, "I would just say, a group of individuals, probably located in more than one state" and a group they believe will continue on killing. Gannon agrees and the smiley face calling card is what makes him convinced the deaths are connected. He says the smiley faces mean "they're happy, as most serial killers are, and very content with their work and what they're doing and the fact that they're thwarting police." Their theory seems to have struck a nerve as, since the theory was first publicly aired, the public has come forward with the names of other potential victims.

Tags: edited by Port1080, written by MayorBob, serial killers, mysterious deaths, smiley face, death (all tags)

This story: 16 comments (3 from subqueue)
Post a Comment
1

Ban the Smiley Face!

pO157.

Wed Apr 30, 2008 at 12:43:27 PM EST

5.00 (funny)

As noted in my editorial comment, this is not the first alleged maniac (or group of maniacs) to use the smiley face as their symbol of death. Luke Helder is another one, in recent memory.

I, for one, think this country will be safe only when the scourge of smiley faces are swept from our streets. Think of the children!

2

^ 1

As a serial killer, Helder was a bust.

MayorBob.

Wed Apr 30, 2008 at 12:50:21 PM EST

4.50 (informative, interesting)

Come on, the only thing he ever did was blow pipe and nail bombs up and grievously wound about six people. In the National Serial Killer League, it's all about confirmed (and alleged) kills. In baseball terms, Helder was a career doubles hitter while Gacy and Ridgway were Hank Aaron and Babe Ruth (I refuse to recognize any dingers Bonds hit after he downed his first 'roid). If this is a group then they might be trying to turn serial killing into a team sport.

Illegitimi non carborundum.

3

Main Link is Wrong

logan.

Wed Apr 30, 2008 at 02:48:20 PM EST

5.00 (brilliant)

The main link (killing as many as 40 victims thus far) is a link to a story about John McCain opposing "a Senate bill that seeks equal pay for women because it would lead to more lawsuits." Can we get a corrected link please?

-=Logan
Research, facts, a Republican needs not these things

4

^ 3

Right you are.

MayorBob.

Wed Apr 30, 2008 at 02:58:32 PM EST

4.00 (informative)

I know I had given thought to writing up a story about the failed piece of gender equity legislation with McCain's part in it. Anyhow here's the proper link -- killing as many as 40 victims thus far -- now if port, fastdog or Ace would replace it, the story would read a whole lot better.

Illegitimi non carborundum.

13

^ 4

picked the wrong button...

1fastdog.

Thu May 01, 2008 at 06:35:13 PM EST

none

Rewired the link earlier, Mayor, and thought I replied to this comment to tell ya so. But no, my button clicking led me astray and now that comment sits all by itself, looking wildly out of place and mostly incoherent in its lonely orbit....

Somewhere in my soul, there's always Rock -n- Roll... Joe Strummer

14

^ 13

Lonely little comment, all by itself in the world.

MayorBob.

Thu May 01, 2008 at 06:54:19 PM EST

none

It's all right.  Because, after all, had I not screwed up the link in the first place we wouldn't have an exiled comment.

Illegitimi non carborundum.

6

Patterns and connections

Steve Urkel.

Wed Apr 30, 2008 at 04:43:01 PM EST

5.00 (interesting)

Once you start looking for patterns, it can be easy to find them where they don't really exist (even something as improbable as "Sinsiniwa" can still be a coincidence). Obviously a lot depends on evidence the investigators claim to have but haven't released yet. Some doubts about this theory:

What prior examples do we have of serial killers working as a group? Off the top of my head I can think of the Manson family, and the Ripper Crew*, and that's about it. How can a multi-state association of pyschopaths remain a stable organization over a period of years?

The smiley faces are not conclusively linked to the crime scenes, they are found where the investigators think the bodies intially entered the water.

*The leader of the Ripper Crew did construction work for John Wayne Gacy. That's an odd connection too, isn't it?

7

^ 6

Re: Patterns and connections

PenitenziAgite.

Thu May 01, 2008 at 12:54:27 AM EST

none

The Hillside Strangler(s) and the DC Snipers come to mind.

I believe the Manson family is a little mischaracterized as 'serial killers', more along the lines of 'killing sprees' or 'thrill-kill cult'.

Some theorize that the Zodiac was more than one person, but that's just a theory.  

sierra tango foxtrot uniform

10

^ 7

Re: Patterns and connections

Steve Urkel.

Thu May 01, 2008 at 04:36:43 PM EST

none

There've been a number of pairs of closely associated killers. But a multi-state group?

12

^ 10

Re: Patterns and connections

PenitenziAgite.

Thu May 01, 2008 at 05:52:52 PM EST

none

Not that I could find.  But, as with all things human, I'm sure this phenomenon is evolving.

sierra tango foxtrot uniform

8

^ 6

There's The Rub

uncarved block.

Thu May 01, 2008 at 09:23:10 AM EST

none

    The problem on the other side is that serial killers (in general) hope to use the lack of communication among local law enforcement to continue their runs, unless they're as outrageous as someone like the BTK strangler or Zodiac, who were playing the "catch me if you can" game with law enforcement. Gacy and Dahmer just wanted to go on as long as they could, for examples the other direction. While I have serious reservations that these deaths are connected, I'm not going to fault a couple detectives who are willing to make a case, because so many other killers could have been stopped or slowed down if cops had shown this kind of initiative.
    The smiley faces are dubious; I want to know if it's some kind of local or regional graffiti first. If there's nearly a reflexive connection between a death and this particular style, then the cops may be on to something.
    The bigger argument, IMO, against this actually being serial killings is the peacefulness of the deaths. Most serial killings involve sex (rape, really), and a whole lot of suffering on the part of the victim, neither of which are present here. (Yes, there's been nurses who strangle patients.) What's the fun in just shoving someone in a river? I guess you get to see them drown, but it seems awfully remote emotionally, especially as so many of these happened at night when a killer couldn't get a good view of the suffering. But perhaps it's best not to be too rational about a typically irrational group of people.
    Oh, on a guess, "group" probably really means "pair", but the detectives don't want to be that specific. But that's just a guess.

Ex ignorantia ad sapientiam; e luce ad tenebras

11

^ 8

Re: There's The Rub

Steve Urkel.

Thu May 01, 2008 at 04:44:36 PM EST

none

Good points. They've suggested throwing the bodies in the water has obscured what the killers have done to the victims. Which to me is another indicator of how shaky this is.

15

^ 11

Re: There's The Rub

JimmyHavok.

Thu May 01, 2008 at 09:14:46 PM EST

5.00 (informative)

It's pretty easy to tell if someone has died of drowning (water in the lungs), and a dunking won't remove the traces of bruising such as would happen in a waterboarding...it might even bring them out.  So the theory that the drowning obscures traces of something else seems pretty shaky to me.

16

^ 15

Re: There's The Rub

Steve Urkel.

Thu May 01, 2008 at 10:56:25 PM EST

4.00 (interesting)

Yeah, it looks like trying to fit the facts with a pre-accepted hypothesis.

5

Re: The Smiley Face Of Death. Serial Killers Amon

stevetherobot.

Wed Apr 30, 2008 at 03:04:38 PM EST

none

Thanks for all the links MB.  I've linked to this from my column on Newsvine.

9

Fixed!

1fastdog.

Thu May 01, 2008 at 02:00:44 PM EST

none

I'll have port shot at sunrise for that :-)

Somewhere in my soul, there's always Rock -n- Roll... Joe Strummer

This story: 16 comments (3 from subqueue)
Post a Comment