Business

News Flash: Government Employees Misuse Tax Dollars

pO157.

Posted to Business on Fri Apr 11, 2008 at 10:11:07 AM EST (promoted by port1080). RSS.

An audit by the Government Accountability Office determined that nearly half of all government "purchase card" transactions that were reviewed were improper.  

The Government Accountability Office is the investigative arm of the US Congress. Its mission is to examine the use of public funds and property and ferret out fraud, waste and mismanagement. It did just that in a new report (pdf) which found that 48% of large transactions made by government purchase cards (credit card accounts that are supposed to be used for government business or for contract payments) between 7/05 to 9/06 were improper.

Over three hundred thousand employees are authorized to use purchase cards. Some of the more egregious violations include:

-A Forest Service Employee who used "convenience checks" attached to the card to give $640,000 to a boyfriend.

-A postmaster spent $1,100 on online dating services and porn for his government computer. He was allowed to pay back the money and spent the rest of his time until retirement on paid sick leave.

-The postal service spent $13,500 on a single dinner at a swanky restaurant for 81 guests. The tab included over 200 appetizers and 40 bottles of liquor such as expensive wines and hard liquor like Courvoisier, Belvedere and Johnny Walker Gold. A spokesman defended taking postal customers to dinner, and said it is normal to have a drink with a business dining experience.

-$360 was spent at an Ecuardoran adult boutique to buy lingerie for State Department Employees undergoing a "jungle drug training program." While admitting that the charges looked questionable the department supported them.

Senator Coleman (R-Minn) requested the study. Furious by the results, he announced "Too many government employees have viewed purchase cards as their personal line of credit. It's time to cut up their cards and start over."

Tags: edited by Port1080, written by pO157, Leon Phelps, Courvoisier, Belvedere, Johnny Walker Gold, anal probe, Topeka (all tags)

This story: 10 comments (3 from subqueue)
Post a Comment
7

Total amount?

jwb.

Sun Apr 13, 2008 at 03:45:05 PM EST

4.33 (astute, interesting, interesting)

The report does not mention the total amount of fraud, but I would be willing to bet that it is like a gnat on the ocean of macroscopic government waste.  300,000 individuals with $2,500 lines of credit can hardly do damage on the scale of defense procurement fraud, misplaced palettes of cash in Iraq, etc.

8

^ 7

Re: Total amount?

JimmyHavok.

Mon Apr 14, 2008 at 02:21:41 AM EST

5.00 (astute, interesting, interesting)

misplaced palettes of cash in Iraq

I got to talking with some Boy Scout adult leaders (we were doing some volunteer work together) about a year or so ago, and one of them told me an interesting tale.  His son-in-law was a captain in the Army, flying helicopters in Iraq.  His crew and two other helicopters were assigned to drop three pallets in the desert.  As they flew away, they saw pickup trucks come in out of the darkness to retrieve the pallets.

One of his men said he'd gotten a look at the cargo, and it was bales of money.

It's hearsay, but it's still pretty interesting.

9

^ 8

Re: Total amount?

3fingerspointback.

Wed Apr 16, 2008 at 08:45:47 AM EST

5.00 (informative)

That sounds like SOP for the CPA:

In one notorious incident in April 2004, $1.5 billion in cash that had just been delivered by three Blackhawk helicopters was handed over to a courier in Erbil, in the Kurdish region, never to be seen again. Afterwards, no one was able to recall the courier's name or provide a good description of him.

(is 3fingerspointback)

10

^ 9

Re: Total amount?

JimmyHavok.

Wed Apr 16, 2008 at 03:19:07 PM EST

none

I wonder if it was the same incident, or yet another?

1

Re: News Flash: Government Employees Misuse Tax Do

port1080.

Fri Apr 11, 2008 at 11:19:31 AM EST

none

How do they get away with this stuff?  At my university, I've at various times been able to "expense" some things, like meals or travel expenses, when going to conferences or doing work for the university.  Every item expensed is reviewed and approved by someone in the accounting department.  You can get away with small things (like, we're not supposed to be allowed to charge alcohol purchases during meals to the university tab), but I have to hope that if I charged my dating service fees to the school that someone would catch that!  If this is really that endemic, each department should have a GAO rep looking over their shoulder - the savings from preventing the fraud should make up for the added costs.

2

^ 1

The System Is Only As Good As The Watchdog.

MayorBob.

Fri Apr 11, 2008 at 12:09:14 PM EST

none

These cards are issued to a set number of people who might need to to go out and purchase supplies or services with them.  They are supposed to be for authorized purchases only, of course.  But there is no real up front approval process the card holder needs to go through before they use the cards.  And, to merchants processing the purchase, they're just another piece of plastic used to pay for stuff -- there is nothing on the card, or in the system, which would preclude them being used as inappropriately as these were.  The key is supposed to be timely review and reconciliation by a government purchase card person.

Each government agency has to appoint someone or a group of someones responsible for scrutinizing the monthly totals for purchases as they get spit out by the government purchase card issuer (used to be Diners Club years ago -- I'm not sure who it is now).  The system works to correct abuses when the scrutinizer does his or her job.  However, there are any number of activities and agencies in the government where performing these duties is, shall we say, lax.  Usually, these things will end up being exposed, but you may have to wait for an audit or IG for that to happen and literally millions of dollars of unauthorized and inappropriate purchases could go undetected.  And then, of course, the beheadings and floggings ensue.

Illegitimi non carborundum.

3

^ 1

Re: News Flash: Government Employees Misuse Tax Do

pO157.

Fri Apr 11, 2008 at 12:51:00 PM EST

none

Seriously. The system here works like this: I buy everything up front on my credit card and eventually when some overpaid and underworked person in administration gets around to it I get my money back. Last year I had to rent a car for trip to a conference. The lady in charge of working with the car rental agencies told me to get certain types of those optional insurances but not others. Fine. So I get back, turn my receipts in and go pick up my check. A secretary tells me my payout was reduced by $70+ because I ordered "unauthorized insurance" and so I had to pay for it out of my own budget. This was after I voluntarily reduced my own per diem to come in under budget for the trip (we were going to a place authorized about $160 a day). I was NOT happy.

So why do government agencies allow so much waste to get through? My sister used to do auditing at an earlier job. Her department supposedly found some idiot booking a trip to see family in India on a company purchase card. Their solution? Fire him and probably go after him civilly for the money. Why can't the government get it together and do that? How about a policy of: if we catch you buying lingerie for your hot Latina with government funds you get a one way ticket to FPMITA Prison? I bet that would be a deterrent for all the people thinking of sending their boytoys six figure sums with balance transfer checks.

Also, port1080, when did you start using an online dating service? How's that working out for ya?

4

^ 3

Re: News Flash: Government Employees Misuse Tax Do

port1080.

Fri Apr 11, 2008 at 01:00:27 PM EST

none

Also, port1080, when did you start using an online dating service? How's that working out for ya?


Ass.  It was a hypothetical, drawn from the original writeup, where it was noted that "-A postmaster spent $1,100 on online dating services and porn for his government computer."  I neither pay for online dating services nor porn.

5

^ 1

Re: News Flash: Government Employees Misuse Tax Do

thefadd.

Fri Apr 11, 2008 at 01:34:59 PM EST

none

When I was in student government, one of my compatriots "misappropriated" over $15,000 in funds. I, as a fellow student, was the one who caught her--not any of the checks and balances in the profession finance department. One of the transgressions included altering a $360 rental invoice to read as a $3600 invoice. It was amazing to see just how easy it had been for this person to get away these acts--more then a year before I came on the job and did my job thoroughly enough to dig up everything.

It is easy to buy small plaster models of what you think life is like.

6

^ 1

Re: News Flash: Government Employees Misuse Tax Do

skeeter1.

Sat Apr 12, 2008 at 01:03:58 AM EST

none

"How do they get away with this stuff?"

Good question.  When I was working at a hospital, and we had to travel, we had to put it on our personal credit card.  When we got back, we had to submit a detailed summary of charges and then get reimbursed.  No booze, no hookers, no anything besides food, room, and travel expenses allowed.  Might not have been the best system, and it sucked if you didn't have a good credit card with lots of money left on it (I knew people who fell into that category), but the company didn't lose a dime on any of us.

On the other hand, I also worked for a magazine in New York, and it's good to befriend the executive editor.  $250+ lunches on the company tab weren't uncommon.  It might also be partially responsible for why Ziff-Davis (parent company of PC Magazine) recently filed for bankruptcy

there's only one way to find out...

This story: 10 comments (3 from subqueue)
Post a Comment