Business

It's Not Sex, It's SeXXXercise!

MayorBob.

Posted to Business on Sat Aug 30, 2008 at 01:47:43 PM EST (promoted by 1fastdog). RSS.

Stephanie Babines wants everyone to know she's all about fitness first.  As a matter of fact she would like to earn a living helping women become more fit, trim, and limber.  But the zoning officials in Adams Township, Pennsylvania don't want to let her open her business.  What could possibly be objectionable about another having another fitness salon?  According to the authorities in Adams Township, it's not the fitness, it's the method Babines plans on using to get the ladies fit.  According to Babines, they're a bunch of narrow-minded blue noses and she's willing to go to court to prove her point.

Babines is the owner/operator of Oh My You're Gorgeous a ladies' exercise salon which features pole dancing as an exercise regime.  Actually, pole dancing is just one of the exercise programs her salon would offer.  Babines has a master's degree, a day job, and began work on opening her salon back in February.  She leased space in a shopping center and spent (US)$10,000 to refurbish the space to conform to a dance/fitness studio.  Then she applied for an occupancy permit from the township.  The township said no in a rejection letter back to her:

"We recently received information that would classify your business as an `Adult Business,' because of the content of your advertising and information from your websites."
She's been to two separate appeals hearing with the zoning board and both of them resulted in turndowns.  So, it's off to federal court with an assist from the ACLU.  Witold Walczak, executive director for the ACLU in Pittsburgh, said the ban by the township is an attack on Ms. Babines' First Amendment rights.  Walczak noted that pole dancing is not, in and of itself, prurient business and "have become an increasingly popular form of exercise for women around the country, and even in China, a country not known for freedom."  The complaint says that Babines considers "pole dancing to be both an art and a sport, and she believes that pole dancing demonstrates that women can be powerful, physically strong, and beautiful with their clothes on."  All the pole dancing classes offered require participants to be fully clothed.  Gary Peaco, the township code officer who wrote the rejection letter begs to disagree.  During testimony given at the two appeal hearings, Peaco said it didn't matter whether participants were naked or fully clothed.  He referred to the dance routines as "provocative ... containing sexual innuendo" and, therefore, the studio needed to be classified an adult business.  Peaco also said that Babines' web site "said it all" as to whether the business was too sexed-up for the township and commented that the colors selected by Babines were "often associated with sexy and seductive and are favored by porn sites."

Social commentator Violet Blue took a look at pole dancing and found it to be physical, not merely prurient, exercise.  Many people would agree with that as pole dancing is not merely for strip clubs anymore.  In fact, it has become an increasingly popular form of physical exercise around the nation.

Tags: written by MayorBob, edited by 1fastdog, zoning codes, pole dancing, strip clubs, exercise, fitness salons, dance salons, First Amendment, lawsuit (all tags)

This story: 9 comments (3 from subqueue)
Post a Comment
1

Re: It's Not Sex, It's SeXXXercise!

permazorch.

Sat Aug 30, 2008 at 04:36:24 PM EST

none

What, the town doesn't like revenue, or taxes?
I'm not into strip-clubs or pole dancing, myself, but a job's a job, and if splaying oneself around & about a pole is the only way one can get off their ass, and exercise, what's wrong with that?

But, what do I know? I think prostitution should be legalized & unionized (I mean outside of elected officials).

----- The earth may burn, but we will quiver

2

^ 1

Re: It's Not Sex, It's SeXXXercise!

pO157.

Sat Aug 30, 2008 at 08:39:13 PM EST

5.00 (funny, brilliant)

I think prostitution should be legalized & unionized (I mean outside of elected officials).

Sorry sir, I know you picked Kim, the 109lb Korean college sophomore, but we're afraid 375lb Bea has seniority. She'll be down as soon as she's done chain smoking out back at the loading dock. After all, Union says she gets a break.

3

What I wanna know...

Lou.

Sat Aug 30, 2008 at 09:14:11 PM EST

none

How many pron sites did the cop have to go to come up with the "porn sight color scheme" deduction?

It's the end of the world as we know it, and I feel fine

4

^ 3

He's not even really a cop.

MayorBob.

Sat Aug 30, 2008 at 09:21:22 PM EST

none

He's the township code enforcement officer.  Which means when he's not figuring out the color schemes of pron sites, he's out there writing citations for trash and unkempt yards.  It's the sort of work that creates self-important little pricks who basically answer only to themselves.  Then there was that one who was a real doozy.

Illegitimi non carborundum.

5

not just pole work

gerrymander.

Mon Sep 01, 2008 at 12:47:50 PM EST

none

Doesn't Peaco have a point? Babines has deliberately developed a fitness club which emphasizes sexuality. Not just the pole dancing classes, but also classes on "tantric toning," striptease, and both basic and advanced lap dance classes. Oh, yeah, and the class entitled "SeXXXercise" isn't exactly subtle. Add the various party packages, and it's pretty clear where the emphasis of the business lies. Certainly there are plenty of other options as well, but it's hard to deny the overtly sexual aspects.

Apart from the zoning restrictions, the primary identifier of an adult business is the exclusion of patrons under adult age. That's not necessarily a bad thing. There's nothing wrong with celebrating sexuality, but not everyone is sexual -- and that's especially true of children, who would by definition be prevented from entering Babines' club under an adult business license.

It sucks that Babines wasted a lot of capital prior to getting a business license, but maybe she should have thought about that before spending the money.

9

^ 5

Re: not just pole work

skeptic.

Tue Sep 02, 2008 at 08:53:56 AM EST

5.00 (astute)

I don't think that it is reasonable to expect that any fitness club will be entirely divorced from sexuality.  Why do people want to exercise anyway?  True, there are purely health-related reasons, since obesity is a serious health risk, nonetheless, most people who go to health clubs - it may even be ALL of them - have at least some interest in making themselves more sexually attractive.  Even those who are already married, and therefore not in search of a mate, still like to be attractive to their spouse.  Babines is merely placing a greater emphasis on this aspect of fitness.

6

^ 5

Re: not just pole work

Lou.

Mon Sep 01, 2008 at 01:37:01 PM EST

none

You may have a point...however, I took a look at the site and it doesn't make it clear (afaicc) if it's all ladies only or mixed.  Ladies only?  Innovative exercise club that focuses on a woman's goddess-like sexuality.  Can the fellers come in?  She might have some 'splainin' to do.

It's the end of the world as we know it, and I feel fine

7

^ 6

Re: not just pole work

gerrymander.

Mon Sep 01, 2008 at 07:37:58 PM EST

none

Can the fellers come in?

Why should that matter, if (as Babines would have it), "pole dancing to be both an art and a sport, and she believes that pole dancing demonstrates that women can be powerful, physically strong, and beautiful with their clothes on." Are you really going to say that men should be forbidden from areas where women perform art or sports? Even under a general business license?

8

^ 7

Re: not just pole work

Lou.

Mon Sep 01, 2008 at 07:39:53 PM EST

5.00 (astute)

Curves

It's the end of the world as we know it, and I feel fine

This story: 9 comments (3 from subqueue)
Post a Comment