Diary

How Do You Beat A Traffic Ticket?

MayorBob.

Posted to Diary on Thu Sep 25, 2008 at 09:31:59 AM EST. RSS.

You're tooling down the interstate, zipping lane to lane, casually passing car after car when you hear the shrill sound of the siren behind you and you see the flashers atop the police cruiser driven by the officer who wants you to pull over.  Before you bring your car to a halt you realize a couple of things: you were doing 10 to 20 miles over the speed limit; you're aware you don't really have an excuse for speeding; and you need the ticket and the points like you need a hole in the head.  As you reach for your license, registration and insurance you know the only way out is to come up with a stunning ploy.  What do you do?  Actually, your options are wide open.  At least there are ten good ones, according to jalopnik.com -- everything from "I gotta poop" to crying like a baby to disarming humor to lying like a cheap rug to being uber polite.  What's your favored approach?  Better yet, what's actually worked for you?

Tags: (all tags)

This story: 35 comments (0 from subqueue)
Post a Comment
6

Delay, Delay, Delay

thefadd.

Thu Sep 25, 2008 at 01:54:39 PM EST

5.00 (interesting)

I have two pending speeding tickets...from March. Around here, if the cop doesn't show up, you win. So, the best advice I've heard yet is to delay, delay, delay. Wait until the deadline and take your single optional extension. Wait until the deadline again and schedule your court date for the furthest date out. If I really get my ass in gear before November, I'll hire an attorney to go to court for me and have them both extended again. The quota issue will be over and done with for the cop and any number of things could have happened in the intervening months...the guy could have gotten a promotion, demotion, a transfer, a suspension, retired. The one told me, "you can just take traffic school online for this" so I *know* his ass isn't showing up in court. I'm also doing my best to schedule them near the holidays. They're my first two ever so I'll let you know how they turn out...

It is easy to buy small plaster models of what you think life is like.

7

^ 6

Re: Delay, Delay, Delay

thefadd.

Thu Sep 25, 2008 at 01:58:14 PM EST

none

Here's a similar quote from the comment section in MB's link above:

I've used this trick for family and friends who have gotten a ticket, and it has worked every single time in CA: Once you get the ticket ask for an extension by going online or calling the courts. You're basically guaranteed one extension. Now do a written declaration (Info is on the back of your ticket). Basically get the form online, write it up, and make a lot of fancy diagram/pictures saying how you had to speed to avoid an accident since the other cars were going so fast. Wait a month and you're almost guaranteed getting out of it since cops have to respond in writing on their own time and don't get a day off to go to the court so most don't write a reply.

It is easy to buy small plaster models of what you think life is like.

8

^ 7

Re: Delay, Delay, Delay

profwhat.

Thu Sep 25, 2008 at 02:01:47 PM EST

5.00 (funny, funny)

Now do a written declaration... make a lot of fancy diagram/pictures saying how you had to speed to avoid an accident since the other cars were going so fast.

Stay tuned for the upcoming "How Do You Beat a Perjury Charge?" TNT diary.

10

^ 8

Re: Delay, Delay, Delay

thefadd.

Thu Sep 25, 2008 at 02:25:37 PM EST

none

He he...I'm willing to take my chances that they don't show up at court but if they're honestly not responding to written declarations like this person says, just tell the god's honest truth. They still have to respond to it and if they don't it just goes away.

It is easy to buy small plaster models of what you think life is like.

1

Allow Me:

MayorBob.

Thu Sep 25, 2008 at 09:42:22 AM EST

none

Considering I asked the questions here, I guess I should offer some of my own experiences.  My wife got stopped by a cop one day for running a red light.  The reason she did was she really had to go, no traffic was coming and the light wouldn't turn.  Guess whether the "I've got to go potty" worked.  Right, it didn't, because the cop was an ass and the judge didn't want to hear excuses.  The polite routine has invariably gotten me a ticket in the past.  Believe it or not, the police don't care how polite you are, they just want to issue the ticket.  I got pulled over once by a cop whose siren and flashers weren't working.  I saw him in my rearview mirror with his headlights blinking on and off and pointing me to the side of the road.  He told me he truly appreciated the fact that I pulled over for him, considering his equipment failure, as he handed me the ticket.

What worked once for me was the truth.  I was pulled over for running a stop sign in this Podunk hamlet outside Wilmington, called Elsmere back in 1968.  At any rate, the officer told me I would have to appear in a magistrate's court in a week to answer the charge.  I told him I was on leave from Vietnam and was due to return at the end of the week (all true, so help me Yahweh).  He just folded the ticket and told me to go and wished me luck.  So my success story is over and the floor is yours.

Illegitimi non carborundum.

11

^ 1

LIES

delete me.

Thu Sep 25, 2008 at 04:00:34 PM EST

5.00 (funny, funny)

I just told a cop today that I was on leave from Vietnam, and the bastard still gave me a ticket.

- derumi (del-me)
"Bobby Fischer? Man, that guy is crazy!" - Mike Tyson

13

^ 11

Here's where you went wrong.

MayorBob.

Thu Sep 25, 2008 at 04:14:40 PM EST

5.00 (brilliant, astute)

You probably didn't say: "My friend, I'm a POW on leave from Vietnam."

Illegitimi non carborundum.

2

^ 1

Re: Allow Me:

pO157.

Thu Sep 25, 2008 at 10:51:25 AM EST

none

I've been pulled over twice. Both times on BS crap. Both times given tickets, despite the fact that I did everything "right." My take? Screw being nice or offering excuses (eg incriminating yourself). You are going to get a ticket no matter what.

Don't make the cops job easier in court. Deny everything, but be polite, and fight it in court.

Traffic ticket court record:
2-0. (One I had to show up to beat, the second I got tossed out without setting foot inside a courtroom). Go me.

3

^ 1

Re: Allow Me:

wetkarma.

Thu Sep 25, 2008 at 11:19:12 AM EST

none

When I lived in Georgia, I'd get pulled over every 4-6  months or so - especially when driving at night in Marietta or S.W. Dekalb.  Of the 1/2 dozen times or so I was pulled over while living in Georgia, I always felt it was due (in part) to racism. Conversely whenever I got pulled over in Virginia I either though it was due to my own foolishness (speeding) or the cops intent on meeting their ticket quota. Whether my 'racism' radar is more finely attuned to Georgia, or whether Georgian cops are really more racists I'll let you all decide.

Not that the cops were all white mind you (some were black) - but not many young men of my ethnicity was driving around in a spiffy higher end vehicle and I suspect that a lot of times they used whatever excuse they could think of pull me over and then do the 'Do you mind if I search your vehicle' number.

I do recall that the one time I decided to fight a ticket (cop said he pulled me over for speeding, refused to show me the result of the radar gun) the cop basically perjured himself in court (testified as how I sped off from a stop light - while making a left turn at the same light). Even though I pointed out several inconsistencies to the judge, I got the ticket anyway.

Memory is a strange bell, jubilee and knell.

4

^ 3

Re: Allow Me:

joshv.

Thu Sep 25, 2008 at 11:39:02 AM EST

none

Did you ever let them search your vehicle?

5

^ 1

Re: Allow Me:

gerrymander.

Thu Sep 25, 2008 at 01:01:50 PM EST

none

The trouble with the "be polite" option is that it doesn't go far enough. "Yes, officer" and "no, officer" are good starts, but the real key is admit you screwed up. This works best where there's some plausible cognitive dissonance already -- a confusing intersection, road work, and so on -- and even there it's dependent upon factors you can't control, like how close the cop is to his quota. (I disregard immediately any complaints about admitting guilt in front of an officer; most jurisdictions have written laws in such a way that getting a ticket = guilt.)

Handing the cop my license/insurance info with a "yeah, I though I had the light, but I was wrong" is the only strategy which has ever gotten me out of a ticket. (Not that I've made an exhaustive test of the linked list, mind.)

9

^ 5

Re: Allow Me:

pO157.

Thu Sep 25, 2008 at 02:22:48 PM EST

none

(I disregard immediately any complaints about admitting guilt in front of an officer; most jurisdictions have written laws in such a way that getting a ticket = guilt.)

I found out from my ticket issued by the NYSP that in my case shutting up is the right choice. The officer is required to note the facts of the case on a "Supporting Deposition" (even for traffic infractions) which include statements on whether or not the motorist admitted guilt. If the cop is going to give you a ticket anyway, fine, but you don't want that in court that you admitted the guilt to get out of a ticket.

12

Re: How Do You Beat A Traffic Ticket?

delete me.

Thu Sep 25, 2008 at 04:04:49 PM EST

none

Drive much faster than you were doing.

- derumi (del-me)
"Bobby Fischer? Man, that guy is crazy!" - Mike Tyson

14

Never Crossed My Mind

uncarved block.

Thu Sep 25, 2008 at 05:53:53 PM EST

none

    I've never been pulled over on my bicycle, and wouldn't say "boo!" if it happened. Why? Because cyclists are pretty much invisible, and if I got noticed, chances are good A) I did something to deserve it, or B) the cop was looking for a reason to fuck with me. Neither reason gives me much cause to yap too much, either during or after the ticketing.

Ex ignorantia ad sapientiam; e luce ad tenebras

15

^ 14

Re: Never Crossed My Mind

delete me.

Thu Sep 25, 2008 at 07:52:05 PM EST

none

My dad had an anecdote about a friend of his getting ticketed on his bicycle. He was zipping in and out of traffic on Okinawa, and the speed limit was 20km/h.

More recently, here in Portland, they did a crack-down on bicyclists and motorists that were running red lights. A little bit of screaming about persecution from the bicyclists. Personally I wish that everyone on 2, 3, and 4 wheels here would quit considering various red symbols as optional.

- derumi (del-me)
"Bobby Fischer? Man, that guy is crazy!" - Mike Tyson

16

^ 15

Yeah

uncarved block.

Fri Sep 26, 2008 at 08:27:41 AM EST

none

    The hardest part about being a cyclist can be other cyclists-- the stupid shit I see even in my limited time on the road is embarrassing.
    Heh. After being in Tucson for a couple years, Portland traffic looks like heaven every time I go back to visit. Oh, sure, there's the typical crap that goes on in downtowns everywhere, but in comparison, it's pretty damn tame. Something about actually having a freeway system that works, on a guess.

Ex ignorantia ad sapientiam; e luce ad tenebras

22

^ 16

Re: Yeah

delete me.

Fri Sep 26, 2008 at 02:15:05 PM EST

none

Portland's freeway system works? What the hell is Tucson like?!

- derumi (del-me)
"Bobby Fischer? Man, that guy is crazy!" - Mike Tyson

33

^ 22

Shocking, Isn't It?

uncarved block.

Fri Sep 26, 2008 at 06:53:46 PM EST

5.00 (informative)

    Actually, all things are relative, I guess-- there are certainly a lot of faults in Portland, mostly when old roads get tons more traffic than the original planning ever expected. But there's still freeways that will get you within a short (one mile) drive of most locations across the city.
    Tucson, OTOH, has freeways that pass by the outside of the city, but not through it. There are three main roads the run east-west, which as the city is a long rectangle (for the most part) running that way, is the way most folks have to travel for, well, just about everything. Malls, restaurants, businesses, houses, all line both sides of the streets: think Sandy Boulevard with one more lane one each side. Except that the speed limit is posted at 45, and as this is the commuter routes, many drivers will close in on 60 given the chance. Add in lagging turn lights (one of the only places in the nation) and you have a recipe for lots of frustration, and a fair number of accidents, both cars and pedestrians.
    So yes, Portland has traffic jams, especially on I-5, but the frustration isn't there every single time you get on that stretch of road; a trip down Speedway in Tucson is a pain in the ass from 7 am to 7 pm, Monday through Saturday. And if you're a cyclist . . well, it scares the hell out of me, but then I have a good imagination, probably too good. I can walk to work now, and run most errands, and don't miss the hassle at all.

Ex ignorantia ad sapientiam; e luce ad tenebras

17

^ 15

Re: Never Crossed My Mind

joshv.

Fri Sep 26, 2008 at 09:36:54 AM EST

none

I look at it this way - though I know I am breaking the law, the stop signs are there to protect pedestrians and cars from other cars - bikes don't really enter into the safety equation.  

If I run a stop sign on my bike, I am only putting myself at risk.  There is no chance of my injuring a car's occupants if I hit a car, or a car hits me.  I guess I could injury a pedestrian, but I have a much narrower cross section than a car, lower mass, lower speed, and am much more aware of pedestrian traffic than the typical driver.

19

^ 17

Re: Never Crossed My Mind

port1080.

Fri Sep 26, 2008 at 10:01:49 AM EST

5.00 (astute, astute)

If I run a stop sign on my bike, I am only putting myself at risk.

Until a car driver has to swerve or jam on his breaks to miss you and ends up causing a major accident.  I drive to work every day through a college town that has a lot of commuter and bicycle traffic, and I've seen far more traffic problems & near miss accidents caused by ignorant pedestrians and bicyclers than anything else.  Traffic laws go both ways!  They're meant to protect pedestrians and bicyclers, but for them to work everyone, not just car drivers, has to obey them!

20

^ 19

Re: Never Crossed My Mind

joshv.

Fri Sep 26, 2008 at 10:54:02 AM EST

none

Well, I'll admit there are a lot of idiot pedestrians and cyclists - but I've never caused a car to swerve or have an accident.  I don't just run stop signs/lights willy-nilly.  And again, I realize I am breaking the law - but sorry, stopping and starting on a bike every block just doesn't work for me - I'll take the ticket if they can catch me.

21

^ 20

Habits

profwhat.

Fri Sep 26, 2008 at 02:12:20 PM EST

5.00 (brilliant)

So I like talking to other bike commuters.  Most of them can give you a story about an accident they've been in, or at least a close call.  But one commuter I met, a gray-bearded guy who had been commuting regularly since the 1970s, told me he had never been in a single accident.  His secret?  Obeying traffic laws.  All of them.

When you come to a red light, carefully look all ways, confirm that there are no cars coming, and confirm that cars won't even have to brake because of you, then it is safe to run the red light.  Here is the problem: running red lights becomes a habit.  You grow accustomed to this ability, and you forget its inherent danger and the need to be very careful each time.  You eventually screw up.  By contrast, someone who makes a habit of obeying the law stays safe, every time.

24

^ 21

Re: Habits

joshv.

Fri Sep 26, 2008 at 02:28:22 PM EST

4.00 (astute)

Well, these days I am probably an atypical bike-commuter, as I have a 17 mile lone bike path 2 blocks from my door, that just so happens to take me to within about 10 blocks of work, so I only have about a mile each way on city streets.  But I used to commute 12 miles a day, right through the most dense parts of the city (Chicago).  Did that for about a year, never had a single accident, and never stopped for a red light or stop sign unless there was cross traffic.  Maybe graybeard is right, and it will catch up to me, but I think I am much more likely to get hit by a car whose driver is disobeying traffic rules, than I am to suffer or cause harm because of my own bad habits.

34

^ 21

Yes And No

uncarved block.

Sat Sep 27, 2008 at 12:44:10 PM EST

none

    The one time I got hit by a car was in broad daylight. Coming home from playing hoops at noon, a couple girls in an intersection turned left across my lane, and I ended up on their hood-- after braking for about five feet, which prevented any serious injury. (Went to work, actually, and had the bike fixed the next day.) So I'm not one to believe that following the laws studiously is enough. But the wise path is to follow them as much as possible, that's for sure. I never run red lights*, and only run stop signs in the back streets, when traffic is light and visibility is good.
    The problem for cyclists is that a "full stop" is, as I was taught, putting one foot on the ground; I believe that's the law for motorcyclists as well. Problem is, that's an absurdly high standard, a bit like having motorists turn off their motor at every light. That little bit of momentum between 2 mph and a full stop doesn't seem like much, but over a long ride, it adds up. And the safety reduction would need calculus to measure, it's so small.

     *It constantly amazes me what motorists will risk just to avoid a light. Sure, serious accidents are rare, but is it really necessary to risk life and limb just to save a minute or less off your trip? This is different from the slow stop for cyclists, I'd argue, but can see how someone would disagree. Just seems horribly unwise, is all I'm saying.
     

Ex ignorantia ad sapientiam; e luce ad tenebras

35

^ 34

Re: Yes And No

thefadd.

Sat Sep 27, 2008 at 10:04:13 PM EST

none

It amazes me when people say things like:

is it really necessary to risk life and limb just to save a minute or less off your trip?

When I drive aware/aggressive like I do most of the time (10-15 mph over the speed limit, pass people doing 5mph under the speed limit on the right, check all directions then run yellows under control) I shave 20-30 minutes off an otherwise 40-60 minute commute which is why I do it. Saving an hour of my day every day of the week is absolutely huge for me and that's absolutely the difference versus driving "safe" which is why I do it.

It is easy to buy small plaster models of what you think life is like.

25

^ 20

Re: Never Crossed My Mind

delete me.

Fri Sep 26, 2008 at 02:28:49 PM EST

none

If you're doing a low-speed California roll and actually looking both ways, I don't see a problem with that. What too many motorists and bicyclists do in the neighbourhood blocks here is just blast through the stop signs without looking. And they get angry if there's a near-collision (especially when you point out you have no stop sign).

- derumi (del-me)
"Bobby Fischer? Man, that guy is crazy!" - Mike Tyson

18

^ 17

Re: Never Crossed My Mind

Lou.

Fri Sep 26, 2008 at 09:48:59 AM EST

none

There is no chance of my injuring a car's occupants if I hit a car, or a car hits me.

But dude...you could scratch the paint...of a car owned by an American.  Sacrilege!

It's the end of the world as we know it, and I feel fine

23

^ 17

Re: Never Crossed My Mind

delete me.

Fri Sep 26, 2008 at 02:23:50 PM EST

none

I've been hit too many times by fast bicyclists to probably ever agree with that view.

Also, if I hit a bicyclist (with a car, never mind anyone's health), it will cost me money no matter who's fault it is. And even if it's better that some bicyclist should get a Darwin award, why should I be the executioner? I have enough trouble sleeping as it is.* Also, hitting a bicyclist with my motorcycle could very well kill me as well as the bicyclist.

*Now if Hitler, Pol Pot and Stalin were alive and regularly rode bicycles, I could probably sleep just fine after running one of them over.

- derumi (del-me)
"Bobby Fischer? Man, that guy is crazy!" - Mike Tyson

26

^ 17

Re: Never Crossed My Mind

pO157.

Fri Sep 26, 2008 at 04:03:02 PM EST

none

I strenuously disagree.

If you go up and over you could go through the windshield become a human projectile and thus seriously injure or kill the occupants of the car.

I've seen it happen several times. I've also seen a guy on a bike get hooked up for DUI. THAT was hilarious.

27

^ 26

Re: Never Crossed My Mind

joshv.

Fri Sep 26, 2008 at 04:21:40 PM EST

none

So when you get arrested from cycling under the influence, what license do they take away?

28

^ 27

Re: Never Crossed My Mind

pO157.

Fri Sep 26, 2008 at 04:28:10 PM EST

none

I have no idea. However, the state I was in (NJ) allowed any tickets received on a bike to be charged to your driver's license. But if you had none, there really would have been nothing to suspend. I suppose they could have put you on the revoked list for a certain period of time.

In this guys case, the cops pretty much had to. The guy drove his bike off a bridge embankment down a cliff and so everybody had to go out there to save his ass. Needless to say he was pretty plastered. I assume the fuzz doesn't drive around randomly pulling over cyclists to give them sobriety checks.

30

^ 28

Re: Never Crossed My Mind

delete me.

Fri Sep 26, 2008 at 04:51:31 PM EST

4.00 (funny)

Saw this six year old that was wobbling pretty badly on his bicycle. I'm sure he was drunk.

- derumi (del-me)
"Bobby Fischer? Man, that guy is crazy!" - Mike Tyson

29

^ 27

Re: Never Crossed My Mind

delete me.

Fri Sep 26, 2008 at 04:50:11 PM EST

none

Your driver's license if you have one. Really.

- derumi (del-me)
"Bobby Fischer? Man, that guy is crazy!" - Mike Tyson

31

^ 29

Re: Never Crossed My Mind

pO157.

Fri Sep 26, 2008 at 05:09:40 PM EST

none

Weird isn't it? I skimmed the code and only saw references to "motorized bicycle." But I assume it is in there, unless the guy in question got arrested for something else and the whole thing is just urban legend and superstition.

32

^ 31

Re: Never Crossed My Mind

thefadd.

Fri Sep 26, 2008 at 05:59:26 PM EST

5.00 (informative, informative)

I always like to bring up this incident in these cases. It seems to vary by state, though. In California you specifically can't get a DUI while operating a bicycle. But you can get a CUI. Apparently some dude in Ohio got so pissed off about getting a DUI for walking his bicycle that he made a youtube movie about it. Washington state at least seems to be the most reasonable about it, while New Jersey is still kinda split. The worst, though, has gotta be getting charged with a DUI for operating your wheelchair. At least the judge threw that one out.

It is easy to buy small plaster models of what you think life is like.

This story: 35 comments (0 from subqueue)
Post a Comment