Of course homosexuality is genetic.
I lean towards thinking that, but sometimes I think that it's a combination of socialization + genetics, or even more likely it occurs during fetal development due to chance hormonal fluctuations - so while it's not exactly genetic, it's not a choice either. Or maybe it's a combination of all of the above - genetic for some people, fetal exposure to unusual hormones in others, socialization in still others. I don't think there necessarily has to be one particular pathway.
Why do you believe that the genetic influences on homosexuality are the same for men as for women
Good point, and one that I hadn't really thought about. Could be the maiden aunts really are just maiden aunts, but I'm 100% sure at least one of the male cousins is gay, and have strong reason to believe a few more are. Maybe I'm just projecting that on the women (who are definitely not "out" if they do trend homosexual).
Allons-y!
12
11
|
Re: Should brown men face-time with each other?
Sun Apr 01, 2012 at 08:18:31 PM EST
|
...even more likely it occurs during fetal development due to chance hormonal fluctuations - so while it's not exactly genetic...
Hormones aren't produced by genes? Where do they come from? Walmart?
... I'm 100% sure at least one of the male cousins is gay...
You could have said "no."
13
12
|
Re: Should brown men face-time with each other?
Sun Apr 01, 2012 at 08:42:13 PM EST
|
pretty sure he's talking about exposure to the mother's hormones, which while they're produced by the mother's glands (and i guess that sort of counts as being "produced by genes") would be different from the baby's own hormones, "produced by" the baby's own "genes."
as far as the whole thing of "it might be a choice," well on that one i don't know what he's on about.
I got more styles than prison got bricks- ain't that some shit?
16
13
|
Re: Should brown men face-time with each other?
Sun Apr 01, 2012 at 09:07:17 PM EST
|
Sort of? Is there a chance that the hormones are off-the-shelf?
17
16
|
Re: Should brown men face-time with each other?
Mon Apr 02, 2012 at 12:14:02 AM EST
|
I have no idea what his understanding of hormones/genetics are, just trying to offer a possible explanation.
I'm sure there's a perfectly scientific explanation for those urges you feel.
I got more styles than prison got bricks- ain't that some shit?
19
13
|
Re: Should brown men face-time with each other?
Mon Apr 02, 2012 at 06:15:38 AM EST
|
as far as the whole thing of "it might be a choice," well on that one i don't know what he's on about.
Did I say it was a choice? I don't think it is - even if it's caused by socialization for some people I think it happens early enough in a kid's life that it's not really something they have a lot of control over. Even if socialization is a pathway, I think there's probably a physiological component to that too - some people are wired to be hetero, some are wired to be homosexual, and some have indeterminate wiring. Those people could be called bi-sexual, but I don't think that every person who has that indeterminate wiring ends up having both hetero and homosexual relationships - socialization would play a strong role with those folks. Some will end up hetero, some will end up homosexual, and some will be truly bi-sexual - but a fairly small number, because there's a lot of pressure to either just be straight, or if you end up in the gay community, to identify as a gay rather than bi (there are a lot in the gay community that deny that being bi is even a valid orientation).
Allons-y!
36
19
|
Re: Should brown men face-time with each other?
Mon Apr 02, 2012 at 11:04:13 PM EST
|
You sure didn't, don't know wtf i was smoking.
also good call on
there are a lot in the gay community that deny that being bi is even a valid orientation
you should see what some in 'the community' have to say about the transgendered- especially transgendered of color. one of the biggest criticisms of the 'gay community' is that a lot of times it would be more properly called the 'white, male, affluent, gay community.' in that respect at least they're just like straights.
I got more styles than prison got bricks- ain't that some shit?
18
12
|
Re: Should brown men face-time with each other?
Mon Apr 02, 2012 at 06:04:17 AM EST
|
Hormones aren't produced by genes? Where do they come from? Walmart?
I was talking about fetal exposure to the mother's hormones, as HFG said. Hormone fluctuation isn't just a matter of genetics - environmental factors can influence it, so can random chance. If the exact same woman could have a heterosexual kid or a homosexual kid, and the fact that she had one or the other was caused by some stress or other environmental factor that led to a hormone fluctuation at a key point in fetal development, I don't see what leverage we gain by calling that "genetic." If this is one pathway to have a homosexual child, then anyone could have a homosexual child. As for the rest of your comment, I won't dignify it with a response - your Socratic trolling is what it is, but I thought incest jokes were beneath you.
Allons-y!
20
18
|
Re: Should blown men face-time with each other?
Mon Apr 02, 2012 at 07:25:30 AM EST
|
Hormone fluctuation isn't just a matter of genetics...
Nothing is.
...environmental factors can influence it...
Not only
can, but almost certainly
do.
I don't see what leverage we gain by calling that "genetic."
But wait...I thought you said it runs in your family?
...I thought incest jokes were beneath you
I can understand why you would want the incident behind you, but I don't think there is anything wrong with humor.
21
20
|
Re: Should blown men face-time with each other?
Mon Apr 02, 2012 at 07:53:27 AM EST
|
But wait...I thought you said it runs in your family?
If you read carefully, I said that it's probably genetic, hormonal, and socialization. In any particular homosexual person, their orientation could have been determined by any one or a combination of those factors. So yes, it runs in families, but there will also be cases that crop up where there is no logical explanation based on genetic inheritance. In those cases it could be hormonal or socialization. I'd guess most cases can be best explained by inherited genetic traits, but I don't think all are.
Allons-y!
22
21
|
Re: Should blown men face-time with each other?
Mon Apr 02, 2012 at 08:58:47 AM EST
|
...it's probably genetic, hormonal, and socialization. In any particular homosexual person, their orientation could have been determined by any one or a combination of those factors
I find it nearly impossible to believe that it could be caused solely by "socialization." As for the hypothesis that it may be caused by abnormal fetal hormonal levels, do you think all women are equally susceptible to such abnormalities?
23
22
|
Re: Should blown men face-time with each other?
Mon Apr 02, 2012 at 09:02:39 AM EST
|
I find it nearly impossible to believe that it could be caused solely by "socialization."
See my discussion of bi-sexuality above - that's what I mean by socialization. I doubt any kid that is born with a distinctly hetero orientation could be socialized to be gay, but I think that at least some percentage of the population have an indeterminate orientation that can be influenced by socialization.
As for the hypothesis that it may be caused by abnormal fetal hormonal levels, do you think all women are equally susceptible to such abnormalities?
I don't know and I don't know enough about the subject offer an informed opinion.
Allons-y!
24
23
|
Re: Should blown men face-time with each other?
Mon Apr 02, 2012 at 09:13:14 AM EST
|
Do you know of any other trait for which there is no observed genetic variability?